Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci Kayseri

What Is a Dissolution of Co-Ownership Case (İzale-i Şuyu)? Sale and Division Procedures

  • Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci
  • 7 min read
Ortaklığın Giderilmesi Davası Nedir? İzale-i Şuyu Satış ve Paylaşım Süreçleri

Among the disputes most frequently encountered within inheritance law and real estate law, which bring family members and relatives face to face in court, are the procedures for terminating co-ownership (shared property). When a real estate property (an apartment, a shop, a plot of land, a field) belongs to more than one shareholder, it is quite difficult to reach a common ground on how the property will be used, whether it will be rented out, or at what price it will be sold. The Turkish Civil Code provides that none of the co-owners can be forced to remain within this legal complication and dispute. If a consensual (agreed) solution cannot be reached among the co-owners, each of the parties has the right to apply to the court and request that the co-ownership be terminated. In legal terminology the dissolution of co-ownership case (ortaklığın giderilmesi davası), known colloquially by its old name as the izale-i şuyu case, is a process that involves strict procedural rules and risks of deprivation of rights. In this comprehensive mega guide, we detail this case, which determines the fate of your real estate, through the most frequently asked questions.

❓ Question 1: In Which Court Is a Dissolution of Co-Ownership Case Filed, and How Does the Process Begin?

🗣️ Answer: In dissolution of co-ownership cases, the court with subject-matter jurisdiction is, under the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK), definitively the Civil Courts of Peace (Sulh Hukuk Mahkemeleri). The competent court is the court of the place where the real estate or properties in dispute are located. For example, if the inherited plots of land or apartments are within the boundaries of Kayseri, the case must be filed before the Kayseri Civil Courts of Peace. For the process to begin, it is enough for only one of the shareholders (co-owners) to file a petition; the approval or participation of all the other shareholders is not needed. The person who files the case is the “plaintiff,” and all the other co-owners shown as holding shares in the land registry take the capacity of “defendant.” After the case petition is submitted to the court, the most critical stage is the process of issuing notifications to all defendants. If notification does not reach even a single shareholder or his or her address cannot be found, the case cannot proceed. It is a legal requirement that all parties be included in the case.

❓ Question 2: Does the Court Terminate the Co-Ownership by “Partition in Kind” (Aynen Taksim) or by “Sale”?

🗣️ Answer: In the case filed, the judge of the Civil Court of Peace first examines ex officio whether the co-ownership can be terminated by “partition in kind” (aynen taksim), that is, division of the property. Partition in kind means physically dividing the real estate among the shareholders. For example, if a large field can be divided under zoning status and agricultural legislation, or if in a multi-unit apartment building condominium ownership can be established so that each shareholder receives one unit, the judge decides that the property be shared in kind. In practice, however, physical division is impossible, especially for a single apartment unit or shop in urban areas, or for agricultural land below the subdivision limit. If partition in kind is not possible or would cause a serious decrease in the property’s value, the court, as a result of the dissolution of co-ownership case, rules that the real estate’s co-ownership be “terminated by sale.” This decision means that the property will be converted into money by being sold by public auction through the enforcement sales office or the sales officer’s office.

❓ Question 3: In Court-Ordered Enforcement Sales, Is the Property Sold Below Its Value? Can the Shareholders Buy It?

🗣️ Answer: After the sale decision becomes final, the file is sent to the Sales Office. First, the current market value of the real estate (valuation, kıymet takdiri) is determined with the assistance of experts. The shareholders have the right to object to this valuation report, and once the report becomes final, the auction dates are announced. The sale is carried out under the provisions of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code by auction in the electronic environment (via the UYAP e-sale portal). The real estate is put up for auction at 50% of the determined appraised value (the experts’ value). The person who gives the highest bid, together with the fees and brokerage charges added on top, becomes the new owner of the real estate. Third parties from outside may participate in this auction, and the shareholders themselves may also bid directly and buy the entire property. Indeed, all shareholders may submit a joint petition to the court and request a decision that “the sale be held only among the shareholders”; however, if even a single co-owner objects to this, the sale must be held publicly (open to everyone).

❓ Question 4: How Can Expatriates Living Abroad Manage Dissolution of Co-Ownership Cases in Their Hometown?

🗣️ Answer: Our expatriate citizens residing abroad (especially in countries such as Germany, France and Belgium) mostly learn very late of these cases filed in Turkey by relatives, or experience great confusion in the notification processes. Leaving the case unattended leads to the experts setting a price far below the real estate’s value, to the auction being missed, and therefore to very serious financial losses. To protect our citizens abroad from these risks, there is absolutely no need for them to come to Turkey in person and waste time in the courthouse corridors. A professional real estate lawyer in Kayseri whom they authorize through the Turkish Consulate in the country where they are can conduct the process remotely from start to finish. As the Akdivit Hukuk law office, we protect our expatriate clients’ rights from our corporate office based in Kocasinan, Kayseri (Mutlu Apt, İstasyon Mahallesi, Sıraselviler Caddesi, Barbaros, Şafak Sk. No:1 Kat:3, No:12, 38080 Kocasinan/Kayseri). By immediately intervening in the file through UYAP (the National Judiciary Informatics System), we monitor the valuation reports, object to low valuations, and ensure that, at the enforcement auction stage, the share our clients deserve is transferred to their bank accounts down to the last kuruş.

❓ Question 5: Who Pays the Costs, Attorney’s Fees and Taxes of a Dissolution of Co-Ownership Case?

🗣️ Answer: The most distinctive legal feature of this type of case is that it is a “double-acting” (two-sided) case. The person who files the case is initially obliged to pay in advance to the court cashier the court fees, notification expenses and expert fees. However, when the case is concluded, all trial expenses incurred, the fees and, if the parties had themselves represented by a lawyer, the attorney’s fees awarded under the tariff are apportioned among all the shareholders in the case “in proportion to their shares” in the land registry. After the sale takes place, the court costs and the auction fees are first deducted from the auction price, and the remaining net amount is transferred to the co-owners’ accounts. For this reason, the thought “I did not file the case, so I am not responsible for the costs” is entirely wrong. Acting with the support of an expert lawyer in Kayseri from the very beginning of the process is the most correct approach for avoiding unnecessary cost items and for conducting strategic negotiations among the co-owners.

This article is general information and is not legal advice for a specific case. Every file is different.

Get in touch to discuss your situation

Call, write on WhatsApp or use the contact form.