Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci Kayseri

What Is a Negative Declaratory Action (Menfi Tespit Davası)? Conditions of the Action to Declare Non-Indebtedness in Enforcement Proceedings

  • Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci
  • 7 min read
Menfi Tespit Davası Nedir? İcra Takiplerinde Borçlu Olmadığının Tespiti Davası Şartları

As a product of commercial life and economic relations, debtor-creditor relationships are constantly formed between individuals and companies. In some cases, however, bad-faith persons may initiate enforcement proceedings for a debt that does not actually exist; people may be left under a heavy burden of debt through forged promissory notes, stolen cheques or baseless invoices. Our legal system has developed a very strong legal mechanism to protect people from whom money is unjustly demanded or who are under the threat of enforcement. The negative declaratory action (menfi tespit davası), regulated in Article 72 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code (İİK) and also known among the public as the “no-debt action,” enables a person to have the court officially declare that he or she does not in fact owe such a debt. We examine this type of action, which is subject to rules that are quite complex both substantively and procedurally, in all its aspects in light of the questions most frequently asked on search engines.

❓ Question 1: What Does a Negative Declaratory Action (Menfi Tespit Davası) Mean, and In Which Situations Should It Be Filed?

🗣️ Answer: In legal language, “menfi” means negative. A negative declaratory action is a type of action in which the plaintiff (the person alleged to be a debtor) asks for a declaration that he or she legally owes no debt to the defendant (the person claiming to be a creditor). This action can be filed at two different times: before enforcement proceedings or after enforcement proceedings. If a person learns that a forged promissory note has been drawn up against him or her, or finds himself or herself under the threat of a debt before enforcement proceedings have even begun, he or she may file this action before the enforcement proceedings in order to prevent attachment risks that may arise in the future. However, the scenario encountered most often in practice is that the person learns of the debt through an “enforcement payment order” arriving at his or her door and is compelled to file this action after the enforcement proceedings. Gambling debts, blank promissory notes signed through fraud, contracts that remained without consideration, or cheques that were not returned even though their value had been paid constitute the most basic subjects of this action.

❓ Question 2: Does Filing a Negative Declaratory Action Automatically Stop the Enforcement Proceedings and Attachments That Have Been Initiated?

🗣️ Answer: The answer to this question changes entirely depending on when the action is filed, and it is of vital importance:

  • If Filed Before Enforcement Proceedings: If the debtor applies to the court before the enforcement proceedings begin, depending on the nature of the case, the court may issue an interim injunction ordering the “stay of enforcement proceedings” in return for the deposit of security (cash or a bank letter of guarantee) of not less than 15% of the debt. In this case, the creditor cannot initiate enforcement proceedings against the debtor until the case ends.

  • If Filed After Enforcement Proceedings: If the creditor has already initiated enforcement proceedings, a negative declaratory action subsequently filed by the debtor does not stop the enforcement proceedings automatically. At this stage, the court may issue not a stay of the proceedings but an interim injunction providing that “the money in the enforcement office’s cashier not be paid to the creditor,” again in return for security of not less than 15%. In other words, the enforcement actions continue, attachments may be made, and even assets may be sold; however, the money obtained from the sale is not given to the creditor and is blocked in the courthouse cashier until the end of the case. For this reason, timing is the most critical parameter for preventing assets from being attached and sold.

❓ Question 3: What Awaits the Parties Who Win or Lose a Negative Declaratory Action? What Is the 20% Compensation?

🗣️ Answer: Negative declaratory actions are sharp cases that carry very serious financial risks (compensation) for both parties. At the end of the case, the court issues one of two decisions:

  • Acceptance of the Action (Debtor Wins): If the court rules that the debtor is right and that no such debt exists, the enforcement proceedings that were initiated are cancelled immediately. All attachments that were placed (salary attachment, vehicle or real estate attachments) are lifted entirely. If it is proven that the creditor initiated these proceedings in a completely unjustified and bad-faith manner, the court orders the creditor to pay “bad-faith compensation” of not less than 20% of the amount of the debt.

  • Dismissal of the Action (Debtor Loses): If the court decides that the debtor is in the wrong, the enforcement proceedings continue more resolutely from where they were left off. If an injunction to stay enforcement was obtained when the action was filed and the creditor therefore could not collect his or her money, the debtor this time is obliged to pay “compensation” of not less than 20% of the claim. In addition, the principal of the debt, the interest and the enforcement costs remain with the debtor.

❓ Question 4: How Can Expatriates Living Abroad File a Negative Declaratory Action Against Enforcement Proceedings Initiated Without Their Knowledge?

🗣️ Answer: Our citizens living abroad (in Germany, France, Austria, etc.) may learn very late of enforcement proceedings and debts against them because of irregular notifications sent to their registered residence address in Turkey (MERNİS, the central population administration system). Because the objection periods (generally 7 days) are missed, the proceedings become final, and attachments may suddenly be placed on expatriates’ bank accounts, fields or vehicles in Turkey. The only legal refuge that expatriates who have missed the deadlines can resort to in order to protect their rights is the negative declaratory action. Our citizens abroad do not need to drop their work and travel to Turkey to manage this dangerous process. With a power of attorney granted at the Turkish Consulate in the country where they are, the entire case process can be conducted remotely. As the Akdivit Hukuk law office, from our office in the centre of Kayseri, at the address in Kocasinan district, İstasyon Mahallesi, Sıraselviler Caddesi, Barbaros (Şafak Sk. No:1 Kat:3, No:12, 38080 Kocasinan/Kayseri), we review all enforcement files on behalf of our clients abroad through UYAP (the National Judiciary Informatics System), raise objections to forged promissory notes and signatures, and coordinate forensic medicine / expert examinations, thereby securing our expatriate citizens’ assets.

❓ Question 5: Who Bears the Burden of Proof in a Negative Declaratory Action? How Do I Prove That I Do Not Owe the Debt?

🗣️ Answer: Although the general rule in our law is that “the person who makes a claim is obliged to prove his or her claim,” in negative declaratory actions who bears the burden of proof varies according to the document (evidence) on which the debt is based. If the person claiming to be a creditor has initiated proceedings on an ordinary claim without any written contract or document between you, it is for the creditor to prove the existence of the debt. If the creditor cannot prove that the debt arose, the debtor wins the case. However, if the creditor holds a promissory note (bono), a cheque or an official contract, the burden of proof shifts entirely and passes to the debtor. This is because a promissory note is, legally, a presumption of the existence of the debt. In this case, the debtor must prove with concrete evidence that the note is forged (objection to the signature), that the debt was paid earlier (bank receipt, voucher), or that the note was signed under fraud or duress. In signature objections, the court sends the file’s handwriting samples and signature specimens to the Forensic Medicine Institution (Adli Tıp Kurumu) for examination. In a trial that contains such sensitive and technical details, forming a professional partnership with an experienced enforcement lawyer in Kayseri will be the wisest move in order not to suffer a loss of rights and to prevent your assets from being attached and sold.

This article is general information and is not legal advice for a specific case. Every file is different.

Get in touch to discuss your situation

Call, write on WhatsApp or use the contact form.