Criminal law is the most sensitive branch of law, in which the state’s power to punish and individuals’ constitutional rights and freedoms come face to face. The upper tier of this branch, which contains the heaviest sanctions, is undoubtedly the offences that fall within the jurisdiction of the Heavy Penal Courts (Ağır Ceza Mahkemeleri). Acts for which the legislator has set the upper limit at more than ten years of imprisonment, or which by their nature deeply shake the social order, are decided in these courts. At every stage of the proceedings (from police/prosecutor statements in the investigation phase to court hearings in the prosecution phase), a single wrong step can have irreparable consequences that may cause people to remain in prison for many years. For this reason, it is essential that the processes be conducted with a professional vision. The subject of a heavy penal court lawyer in Kayseri, which is frequently searched for on the internet, forms the most critical defence pillar of the judicial mechanism. In this comprehensive guide, we examine in the greatest detail, in question-and-answer format, the elements that change the course of criminal proceedings.
❓ Question 1: What Are the Main Offences Within the Jurisdiction of the Heavy Penal Courts?
🗣️ Answer: Under the Turkish Penal Code (TCK) and related legislation, which offence is tried in which court is determined definitively by law. The Heavy Penal Courts, subject to cases in which the laws separately assign jurisdiction, are responsible for cases concerning offences requiring aggravated life imprisonment, life imprisonment and imprisonment of more than ten years. The heavy penal offences most frequently encountered in practice are the following: intentional killing (TCK Art. 81, 82), aggravated injury by reason of its result, aggravated robbery (gasp – TCK Art. 149), aggravated fraud (TCK Art. 158), forgery of official documents, bribery, extortion by a public official (irtikap), embezzlement, offences committed against the security of the state and offences committed against the constitutional order. Each of these types of offences contains extremely complex technical elements within itself. The manner in which the offence was committed, whether it remained at the attempt stage, the presence of grounds for non-punishment/reduction such as the intent to participate or legitimate defence can be established only through meticulous, file-by-file examinations by an expert heavy penal court lawyer in Kayseri.
❓ Question 2: How Can Custody and Pretrial Detention Decisions Be Challenged in a Criminal Investigation?
🗣️ Answer: Contrary to what is assumed, criminal proceedings begin not in the courtroom but in the “investigation” phase, when the judicial authorities learn of the suspicion of an offence. In this phase, the taking of the suspect’s statement by law enforcement (police/gendarmerie) or the Public Prosecutor’s Office is the most dangerous bend in the process. A sentence made in the statement, or a detail left incomplete, may lay the groundwork for a “pretrial detention order” to be issued by the Criminal Judgeship of Peace (Sulh Ceza Hakimliği). In our law, pretrial detention is not a punishment but a temporary “protective measure” to be resorted to as a last resort. For a suspect to be detained, there must be concrete evidence showing the existence of strong suspicion of an offence, and there must be a risk of flight or a danger of tampering with evidence. If these conditions have not been met, an objection must be filed against the detention order, with a reasoned petition of high legal quality, within the statutory period of 7 days. At the stage of objecting to detention, the suspect can be brought to freedom by requesting the application of judicial control provisions (house arrest, signature obligation, travel ban). A criminal defence counsel familiar with practical application in the Kayseri Courthouse and the surrounding regional courts prevents rights violations by following these periods and procedural rules to the letter.
❓ Question 3: What Does “Unlawfully Obtained Evidence” Mean in Criminal Cases, and How Is It Removed From the File?
🗣️ Answer: Under Article 38, paragraph 6 of the Constitution and Article 217/2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK), the alleged offence can be proven only with evidence obtained in a lawful manner. Findings collected by methods contrary to law can never be accepted as evidence in criminal courts and cannot be made the basis of the judge’s verdict. For example, materials obtained as a result of an unlawful search carried out in a home or vehicle without a judge’s order or, in cases where delay would be prejudicial, without a prosecutor’s order; audio and video recordings made secretly without legal permission; or statements taken under pressure, threats or torture are entirely in the position of the “fruit of the poisonous tree.” When a file comes before him or her, a professional heavy penal court lawyer in Kayseri first examines how the evidence presented by the prosecution (the public prosecutor’s office) was collected, chronologically and legally. If unlawful evidence is identified in the file, he or she submits written and oral requests to the court panel for the “rejection of the admission of the evidence” and for its removal from the file, thereby protecting the client’s right to a fair trial to the fullest extent.
❓ Question 4: How Can Expatriates Living Abroad Follow Criminal Cases Opened Against Them in Turkey?
🗣️ Answer: One of the greatest concerns of our citizens living abroad is the risk of being taken into custody at airports (passport control points) when entering or leaving Turkey because of a warrant for arrest or for a statement to be taken. Expatriates may sometimes become the subject of criminal investigations without knowing it because of an inheritance they are party to in Turkey, a real estate dispute, or a post made on social media (allegations of insult or threats). The safest way to learn, while abroad, whether there is an arrest warrant against you and to prevent judicial crises is to grant a power of attorney to an expert law office before coming to Turkey. As the Akdivit Hukuk law office, from our corporate office located in the centre of Kayseri, in Kocasinan district, İstasyon Mahallesi, Sıraselviler Caddesi, Barbaros (Şafak Sokak, No:1 Kat:3, No:12), we query prosecutor’s office and court files in real time through the UYAP system (the National Judiciary Informatics System) on behalf of our clients abroad. For clients who have an arrest or search warrant against them, we prepare the necessary legal groundwork, prevent possible custody situations at airports, and coordinate their defence professionally.
❓ Question 5: Is Hiring a Lawyer Mandatory in Criminal Cases, and What Is the Role of the Defence?
🗣️ Answer: In Turkish criminal procedure law, in investigations and prosecutions concerning offences whose lower limit requires imprisonment of more than 5 years, if the suspect or defendant declares that he or she is not in a position to choose defence counsel (müdafi), or in cases where the law makes it mandatory (children, persons so disabled that they cannot defend themselves, etc.), a mandatory lawyer is appointed by the Bar Association. This is called “mandatory defence counsel” (zorunlu müdafilik). However, considering the high risk of imprisonment and the irreparable restrictions on liberty that heavy penal cases carry, it is vital for people to work with a professional criminal defence counsel of their own choosing, who will spend time specifically on the file and analyse in depth the decisions of the Criminal General Assembly of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay Ceza Genel Kurulu). A lawyer does not merely defend the defendant before the court; he or she also struggles to ensure that a fair trial is held and that the provisions favourable to the defendant (effective remorse, a reduction for unjust provocation, discretionary reduction grounds) are applied in full. A correctly constructed defence on the merits is the most fundamental strength that determines the thin line between acquittal and conviction.



