Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci Kayseri

Is It Legal to Record Audio? Is a Secret Audio Recording Admissible as Evidence in Court?

  • Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci
  • 6 min read
Ses Kaydı Almak Yasal mı? Mahkemede Gizli Ses Kaydı Delil Sayılır mı?

Parties who want to prove they are in the right in legal disputes or criminal proceedings tend to bring every argument they have before the court. With the spread of smartphones, secretly recording telephone conversations or face-to-face talks between parties has become an everyday act. However, in order not to end up in the wrong when you are in the right in a dispute, and not to sit in the defendant’s seat in the courthouse corridors facing claims for compensation or imprisonment, one must know the procedural rules very well. The question is it legal to record audio, which millions of people search for answers to on internet search engines, is subject to extremely strict limits and exceptions under both the Turkish Penal Code and the Civil Code. We examine the evidentiary power of digital data and the legal fate of secret recordings in depth, in a question-and-answer format and in light of the Court of Cassation’s (Yargıtay) most recent case law and statutory provisions.

❓ Question 1: Is Recording a Person’s Voice Without Their Knowledge a Crime under the Turkish Penal Code?

🗣️ Answer: The Turkish Penal Code (TCK) places the confidentiality of individuals’ private lives and freedom of communication under constitutional protection. As a basic rule, secretly recording a person’s conversations without their consent, knowledge and approval, that is, making an unlawful audio recording, is definitely a crime. Under the offence of “Listening to and Recording Conversations between Persons” regulated in Article 133 of the TCK, a person who listens with a device to non-public conversations between persons, or records them with a sound recording device, without the consent of one of the parties, is punished with imprisonment from 2 to 5 years. If these secretly obtained recordings are disclosed unlawfully, uploaded to the internet or played to third parties, the lower limit of the penalty increases further. Therefore, in ordinary circumstances, secretly recording someone’s voice carries very heavy prison sanctions.

❓ Question 2: According to Court of Cassation Rulings, What Are the Exceptional Situations in Which Secret Audio Recording Is Considered “Legal”?

🗣️ Answer: The Criminal General Assembly of the Court of Cassation, taking the ordinary course of life into account, has introduced a vital exception to this strict rule. If a person is being subjected to a crime committed against them (e.g. threat, insult, blackmail, solicitation of a bribe or sexual harassment), and in the face of this suddenly developing event has no opportunity to apply to law enforcement (the police) or to gather evidence, then secretly recording audio in order to prevent evidence that may be lost from being lost and to present it to the competent authorities turns the answer to the question is it legal to record audio into “Yes, it is legal.” The critical criteria here are “not having set a planned trap” and “the existence of a suddenly developing situation.” Recordings made by preparing in advance, hiding a microphone and asking staged questions in order to get the perpetrator to talk are considered entrapment evidence and constitute a crime. However, recording the voice of a person who suddenly phones you and insults and threatens you, because you cannot go to the police at that moment, is considered lawful within the scope of self-defence.

❓ Question 3: Can a Spouse’s Secretly Obtained Audio or Video Recordings Be Used as Evidence in Divorce Cases?

🗣️ Answer: In family law cases, it is common for spouses to record each other’s voices, particularly to prove adultery (infidelity) or domestic violence. According to the settled rulings of the Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, the shared home in which spouses live in a marriage is not entirely a “private life sphere” of the parties; it is a shared living space. Therefore, as long as it does not take the form of planned and continuous surveillance like that of a professional detective, a sound recording device placed in the shared home by a person who suspects their spouse of cheating on them, or the recording in a moment of panic of conversations proving infidelity, can be accepted as “lawfully obtained evidence” in a divorce case. However, this is a very fine line. When the line is crossed, the family court may reject the evidence, and the other party may also bring a criminal case against their spouse before the criminal court. For this reason, it is vitally important to obtain strategic support from an expert criminal defence lawyer in Kayseri or divorce lawyer on how such sensitive digital documents should be submitted to the court.

❓ Question 4: How Can Expatriates Living Abroad Manage Audio Recording and Privacy Violation Cases in Turkey from a Distance?

🗣️ Answer: Our expatriate citizens living abroad (Germany, France, the Netherlands, etc.) are often subjected to insults or blackmail in heated telephone conversations with their relatives, business partners or ex-spouses in Turkey, or conversely, expatriates’ voices are secretly recorded and someone tries to use them against them as leverage. Given the cross-border nature of digital crimes and evidence gathering, the legal proceedings must be conducted in Turkish courthouses. Our citizens abroad do not need to travel to Turkey in person to file these cases, to object to unjust recordings or to manage forensic voice analysis processes. With a power of attorney granted remotely to our corporate law office through the Turkish Consulate in the country where they are, all processes can be started digitally. As the Akdivit Law Office, at our corporate address in Kocasinan, Kayseri (Mutlu Apt, İstasyon Mahallesi, Sıraselviler Caddesi, Barbaros, Şafak Sk. No:1 Kat:3, No:12, 38080 Kocasinan/Kayseri), we protect our expatriate clients’ rights in accordance with the norms of international law.

❓ Question 5: How Can It Be Detected That an Audio Recording Submitted to Court Is Fake or Edited? How Does the Objection Process Work?

🗣️ Answer: Thanks to today’s artificial intelligence technologies (deepfakes, voice cloning software) and editing programs, fake conversation recordings that are impossible to distinguish from the real thing can be produced using a person’s tone of voice. If the other party in the case submits a fake or tampered audio recording that they claim belongs to you, an explicit objection must be raised immediately and within the time limit, concerning “the content of the audio recording, its originality and its being a product of editing.” Upon this objection, the court sends the raw file containing the audio recording (together with the device) to the Council of Forensic Medicine’s Specialised Department of Cybercrime / Audio and Video Examination. Forensic informatics experts examine the sound waves, the background noise floor, frequency interruptions and the code structure, and determine with laboratory precision whether the recording contains any “addition, deletion or editing.” In criminal or civil files where technical expert examinations are this decisive, managing the process with a professional team of lawyers in Kayseri will be your greatest legal shield against conspiracies and slander.

This article is general information and is not legal advice for a specific case. Every file is different.

Get in touch to discuss your situation

Call, write on WhatsApp or use the contact form.