Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci Kayseri

Secret Recordings in Divorce: Evidence or a Headache?

  • Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci
  • 4 min read
Ses Kaydı Boşanma Davasında Delil Olur mu? | Kayseri Avukat

Proving with an audio recording or a video that one’s spouse has insulted or cheated on them seems to many of our clients like “the move that ends the case.” However, the other side of the coin is quite dangerous. While you want to win the case by submitting a recording to the court, you may suddenly find yourself in the defendant’s dock for the crime of “violation of the privacy of private life.” As an experienced divorce lawyer in Kayseri, let us sincerely explain exactly where this famous “secret recording” issue stands in law, along with its risks and possibilities.

Which Recording Is “Lawful” and Which Is “Poisonous”?

There is a very basic principle in law: Evidence obtained by dirty means does not serve justice. However, since divorce cases take place behind the closed doors of homes, the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) allows a very critical flexibility here. Making this distinction with the support of a professional lawyer in Kayseri is of vital importance:

  • Recordings Made “in the Moment”: If your spouse is subjecting you to severe insults, using violence or confessing to infidelity at that moment, pressing the voice recording button on your phone so as not to lose the evidence of that moment is generally considered “lawful.” Because there is no “trap” here, only an effort to capture that moment.
  • Traps and Staging Are Prohibited: Placing hidden cameras in the home in advance, or installing spyware on your spouse’s phone and “waiting for prey” for days, is legally poisonous. Not only does the court not accept these recordings as evidence, they also lay the groundwork for criminal proceedings against you.

Sounds Inside the Home: Shared Space or Private Space?

Many people think, “This is my home too, I can put a device wherever I like.” The reality is not like that. The family home is the most intimate space of both spouses. The Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) may accept recordings made with devices placed inside the home to prove infidelity “if there is no other possibility of obtaining evidence.” However, taking this path without the opinion of an expert lawyer in Kayseri is a great risk. Each file must be examined individually, with a jeweller’s precision.

Don’t Lose While Trying to Win: The Danger of Article 134 of the TCK

The biggest misconception is this: “The judge admitted this recording into the file, so it must not be a crime.” No! Even if the Family Court judge accepts that recording as evidence, if your spouse goes and files a complaint with the Public Prosecutor’s Office, you can be tried for the crime of “violation of the privacy of private life” under Article 134 of the Turkish Penal Code (TCK). In other words, while winning the divorce case, you may face the risk of receiving a prison sentence. You should not act without striking this balance with an expert divorce lawyer in Kayseri.

The Process in Kayseri and Our Approach

As a professional divorce lawyer in Kayseri, we first run the recordings our clients bring through a “legal filter.” If a recording would not protect our client but would instead cause them to go to prison, we turn to safer and lawful methods of gathering evidence (witnesses, HTS records, hotel records, etc.).

As Akdivit Hukuk, we closely follow the current stance of the Kayseri Family Courts on this matter. Our aim is not only to win the case but to keep our client away from every kind of legal risk and bring that difficult process to a safe conclusion. With our team of lawyers in Kayseri, we stand by you with the right strategy and lawful evidence.

This article is general information and is not legal advice for a specific case. Every file is different.

Get in touch to discuss your situation

Call, write on WhatsApp or use the contact form.