Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci Kayseri

Kayseri Enforcement Lawyer: Guide to Enforcement Proceedings, Objection to Debt and Debt Collection

  • Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci
  • 13 min read
Kayseri İcra Avukatı ve Alacak Tahsili Davaları Rehberi

Enforcement and bankruptcy law is a highly technical and operational branch of law that governs compulsory enforcement mechanisms. It allows creditors whose claim has been established before the courts or other competent legal authorities, or who hold a debt document of the kind required by law (cheque, promissory note, invoice, etc.), to collect from debtors who do not pay voluntarily, through the power of the state. In Kayseri and the surrounding provinces, which are the lifeblood of commerce, industry and SME-scale businesses, thousands of new enforcement proceedings are started every day because of unpaid promissory notes, bounced cheques or uncollected invoices, depending on economic fluctuations. Because the procedures carried out at enforcement offices depend on deadlines measured to the day, strict formal requirements and immediate reflexes, even the slightest procedural error can cause a claim to be lost altogether or lead to an unjustified attachment of a debtor’s assets. As a law office with extensive case experience in corporate debt collection and enforcement proceedings in Kayseri, we have compiled the 10 basic enforcement questions that occupy our citizens’ minds the most, together with the legal remedies available.

❓ What Are the Types of Enforcement Proceedings? What Is the Difference Between Enforcement Without a Court Judgment and Enforcement Based on a Court Judgment?

🗣️ In enforcement and bankruptcy law, two basic types of enforcement proceedings operate, depending on the document on which the claim is based. Enforcement Based on a Court Judgment is the type of proceedings used by creditors who hold a court judgment, an arbitral tribunal award or documents that have the nature of a judgment by law (notarised deeds, etc.). In these proceedings it is legally impossible for the debtor to stop the proceedings by going to the enforcement office and saying “I have no such debt”; the debtor can stop the proceedings only by obtaining from the court a decision to postpone enforcement, together with an official receipt showing that the debt has been paid.

Enforcement Without a Court Judgment is the general type of proceedings that may be started, only for monetary claims and claims for security, by persons who hold no court judgment and not even any document at all. In these proceedings a “Payment Order” is sent to the debtor. In enforcement without a court judgment, it is enough for the debtor simply to go to the enforcement office and object to the debt in order to stop the proceedings completely. To prevent the process from dragging on to the creditor’s disadvantage, the correct type of proceedings must be chosen by working with a professional Kayseri enforcement lawyer.

❓ How Many Days Is the Deadline to Object to a Payment Order From the Enforcement Office, and How Is the Objection to the Debt Made?

🗣️ A person who is served with a payment order in enforcement proceedings without a court judgment must object within the legal deadlines in order to stop the proceedings if he or she has no such debt, if the amount of the debt is wrong or if it is time-barred. In proceedings without a court judgment conducted by way of general seizure, the deadline to object to the debt and to the signature is 7 days from the date on which the payment order is served. This period is final and forfeiting.

The objection is made by a clear petition addressed to the enforcement office where the proceedings were started. The petition must contain a clear statement such as “I expressly object to the debt, the interest and all accessories in the payment order served on me; I have no such debt.” If the debtor lives outside Kayseri, he or she may also lodge the objection by correspondence through the enforcement office on duty at his or her place of residence. A properly made objection filed within the deadline automatically stops the enforcement proceedings, and therefore any possible attachment measures, completely.

❓ What Are Enforcement Proceedings Specific to Negotiable Instruments (Cheques and Promissory Notes)? Why Is the Objection Deadline Different?

🗣️ Where the claim is based on valuable instruments regulated in the Turkish Commercial Code, such as a cheque, a promissory note or a bill of exchange, the creditor may start proceedings against the debtor by way of the “Seizure Procedure Specific to Negotiable Instruments.” This type of proceedings is a mechanism that protects the creditor far more strongly than general proceedings without a court judgment and moves ahead much faster.

In negotiable instrument proceedings the deadline to object to the payment order sent to the debtor is 5 days, and the debtor must make this objection not to the enforcement office but by filing a lawsuit directly before the Enforcement Court. The most critical difference is this: in negotiable instrument proceedings, the debtor’s objection to the debt or to the signature does not automatically stop the enforcement proceedings, as it does in general proceedings. For the proceedings to stop, the debtor must obtain from the Enforcement Court judge a “preliminary injunction (stay of the proceedings)” decision, either before or during the proceedings. Because the 5-day period is so short, it is essential to react legally without losing time in cheque and promissory note proceedings.

❓ How Is a Debtor’s Unjustified Objection to Enforcement Proceedings Removed? What Is an Action for Annulment of the Objection?

🗣️ When the proceedings are stopped in enforcement without a court judgment by the debtor’s objection within 7 days, the creditor must turn to legal remedies in order to nullify this objection and continue the proceedings from where they left off. If the creditor does not hold the official documents listed in Article 68 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (İİK) (notarised deed, a document whose signature has been acknowledged, etc.), the creditor must file an “Action for Annulment of the Objection” before the general courts (Civil Court of First Instance or Commercial Court).

The deadline for filing this action is 1 year from the service of the debtor’s objection on the creditor. If, at the end of the trial, the court concludes that the creditor is truly in the right and that the debtor objected without justification, it decides to annul the objection and to continue the proceedings. In addition, a debtor who prolongs the process by objecting to the debt without justification is sentenced to pay “enforcement denial compensation (icra inkar tazminatı)” of not less than 20% of the claim. Before filing the action, applying to mediation is also a legal requirement in enforcement law.

❓ What Is an Action for Declaration of Non-Indebtedness (Menfi Tespit)? What Should a Person Do Who Is Subject to Proceedings Although He or She Is Not a Debtor?

🗣️ The action that a person may bring when he or she is shown as a debtor because of a promissory note or document that does not actually exist, was forged, was given as a favour and later put into proceedings in bad faith, or was paid on time but not taken back from the land registry or the enforcement office, is called an action for declaration of non-indebtedness (menfi tespit). With this action the person asks the court “to declare that he or she has no such debt.”

An action for declaration of non-indebtedness may be filed before enforcement proceedings are started, and it may also be filed after proceedings have been started. An action for declaration of non-indebtedness filed after the proceedings does not automatically prevent the money held at the enforcement office’s cashier from being paid to the creditor. To stop the money from being paid out by the enforcement office, the debtor must obtain a “Preliminary Injunction Decision” by depositing security of 15% of the claim at the court’s cashier. If the debtor wins the case, the proceedings are cancelled, and if the debtor has suffered damage because of the unjustified proceedings, the creditor is obliged to pay 20% bad-faith compensation.

❓ What Is Precautionary Attachment? What Should Be Done to Prevent the Debtor From Hiding Assets?

🗣️ Precautionary attachment is a temporary legal protective measure that a creditor with a monetary claim obtains from the court, before filing the lawsuit or starting enforcement proceedings, in order to secure the debtor’s assets, money and bank accounts and to completely eliminate the possibility of the debtor hiding property.

For a precautionary attachment decision to be obtained, the claim must be due (muaccel) and must not be secured by a pledge. The creditor applies to the Civil Court of First Instance or the Commercial Court and sets out the debtor’s situation, and the court generally issues this decision without a hearing in return for the deposit of security of 15%-20% of the claim. After the precautionary attachment decision has been obtained, the creditor may apply to the enforcement office within 10 days and have an attachment placed suddenly on the debtor’s bank accounts, vehicles or land titles. After the attachment, the main enforcement proceedings must also be started within 7 days. This fast operational process is the most effective weapon in corporate collection management.

❓ What Is Salary Attachment, and What Is the Maximum Portion of a Worker’s Salary That Can Be Attached?

🗣️ After the enforcement proceedings have become final, the enforcement office sends a “Salary Attachment Notice” to the workplace where the debtor works. Once this notice arrives, the employer is obliged to make deductions from the debtor employee’s salary every month within the legal limits and to pay them into the enforcement office’s bank account.

Under Article 83 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (İİK), at most frac{1}{4} (one quarter – 25%) of the salary or wages received by the debtor may be attached. Even if the employee consents, a deduction above this ratio cannot be made before the proceedings. However, ancillary entitlements that the employee will earn on leaving the job, such as severance pay, notice pay or bonuses, are deducted not at one quarter but in full (100%) against the enforcement debt and sent to the enforcement office. If the employer does not apply the salary attachment or delays it, the employer is held personally liable for the debt up to the amount not deducted, and the money is collected from the employer.

❓ What Goods and Items Cannot Be Attached? Can All the Items in the Home Be Attached?

🗣️ In order to protect the principle of the social state and the right to a life worthy of human dignity, Article 82 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (İİK) strictly prohibits the attachment of certain goods and items that are vital for the debtor and his or her family to sustain their lives. With the legal reforms, there are now major restrictions on home attachments.

Accordingly, household items that are necessary for the life of the debtor and his or her family (e.g. refrigerator, washing machine, bed, television, oven, etc.) cannot be attached under any circumstances. However, if there is more than one of the same item in the home (e.g. two televisions or two refrigerators), the second item, other than the necessary one, can be attached. In addition, the tools and equipment the debtor needs in order to practise his or her profession, the debtor’s only home appropriate to his or her circumstances (of a size suited to the debtor’s way of life), and retirement pensions (for SGK pensioners – except for alimony debts) can never be attached without the debtor’s consent. A complaint action must be filed before the Enforcement Court within 7 days against attachments made without justification.

❓ Is There a Prison Sentence for an Enforcement Debt? What Is the Offence of Breach of Undertaking and What Are Its Conditions?

🗣️ Under the Turkish legal system and the Constitution, no one can be punished directly with imprisonment merely because he or she could not pay on time a debt (a monetary debt) arising from a legal contract. In other words, no one goes to prison because of ordinary debts owed to a bank, a person or a company. However, in enforcement law there is one very clear exception to this: the offence of “Breach of Undertaking” (violation of the payment condition).

A debtor who has officially undertaken (promised) at the enforcement office to pay the debt in equal instalments, and who without a justified reason fails to pay even one of these instalments on time, is sentenced by the Enforcement Court, upon the creditor’s complaint, to coercive imprisonment of up to 3 months (tazyik hapsi). For the undertaking to be valid, the amount of the debt, the interest, and the fees and expenses must be calculated down to the last kuruş and recorded in the minutes, and the minutes must bear the triple wet signatures of the debtor, the creditor and the enforcement director. Even if the debtor enters coercive imprisonment, he or she is released from prison immediately the moment the debt is paid.

❓ Why Is It Important to Work With a Lawyer in Enforcement Cases, and What Is the Role of Akdivit Hukuk Law Office?

🗣️ Enforcement and bankruptcy law is an operational field of expertise that depends entirely on legal deadlines measured to the day, on instant file actions at enforcement directorates, and on fast-moving measures such as bank account blocks and land registry attachments. While even hours matter for the creditor in order to prevent the debtor from hiding assets, for the debtor, failing to object within the 7-day period to an unjustified payment order exposes all of his or her assets to enforcement at once.

As Akdivit Hukuk Law Office, serving from our corporate office in Kocasinan, Kayseri, we manage enforcement processes with complete care, using our advanced digital infrastructure, our UYAP (the National Judiciary Informatics System) integrations and our field experience. While converting the uncollected cheque, promissory note and invoice receivables of companies and individuals into liquid funds through legal intelligence and fast attachment methods, we also protect to the maximum the property rights of clients who face unjustified enforcement proceedings, through actions for declaration of non-indebtedness and enforcement objection actions. Our aim is to resolve your financial crises with the least damage and the highest legal gain.

Conclusion: Do Not Leave Your Financial Future and Your Receivables to Chance

Ignoring notices from enforcement directorates, leaving the process to its own devices by saying “I have nothing anyway,” or letting the collection of commercial receivables fall into time-bar can lead to very great economic ruin. Enforcement law protects not only those who are in the right, but those who defend their rights within the legal deadlines, with professional enforcement instruments and with assertive operational reflexes.

Akdivit Hukuk Law Office, at its modern corporate office in Kocasinan, Kayseri, is ready to listen to you, to analyse your enforcement files and your unpaid promissory notes, cheques and invoices down to the finest detail, and to draw up the clearest and fastest collection roadmap for you. For all your enforcement and bankruptcy law disputes, from your enforcement proceedings without or based on a court judgment to objection to the debt, declaration of non-indebtedness, precautionary attachment and breach of undertaking cases, you can contact us at any time and confidently entrust your legal struggle to the defence power of an experienced and dynamic team.

This article is general information and is not legal advice for a specific case. Every file is different.

Get in touch to discuss your situation

Call, write on WhatsApp or use the contact form.