In commercial life, in debtor-creditor relationships, in property leases or in employment contracts, the parties wish to secure against possible losses that may arise or against the risk that the undertaken obligations will not be performed. One of the methods most frequently resorted to in practice to provide this security is for one party to give the other a negotiable instrument (a promissory note) showing that it is indebted. However, this note is not an ordinary debt instrument; it is a part of a contract that guarantees the fulfilment of a certain condition or contract. This type of valuable paper, called a security note (teminat senedi) in everyday speech and in legal language, can, if not structured correctly, be put directly into enforcement by bad-faith creditors and can leave people facing unjust seizure threats. In the light of the most recent precedents of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) guiding the law of negotiable instruments, we examine the legal fate of security notes in depth in a question-and-answer format.
❓ Question 1: What Does a Security Note Mean in Law? What Is the Most Fundamental Difference That Separates It From an Ordinary Debt Instrument (Promissory Note)?
🗣️ Answer: Under the Turkish Commercial Code (TTK), a promissory note is a valuable paper containing “an unconditional and unqualified promise to pay a sum”. That is, an ordinary note is entirely independent of the legal cause behind it (the purchase of goods, a loan of money, etc.) and, when the maturity date arrives, commands that the figure written on it be paid down to the last kuruş. A security note, on the other hand, is a conditional note given not for the payment of a debt, but in order to guarantee the complete performance of a main contract between the parties (e.g. a lease, dealership, employment or construction contract) and the compensation of any loss that arises if there is a breach of the contract or damage. While an ordinary note can be put into enforcement at any time, for a security note to be put into enforcement, first an act in breach of the main contract must have occurred and the creditor must prove through the court that it has genuinely suffered a loss.
❓ Question 2: What Must Be Written on a Note for It to Be Legally Considered a “Security Note”? What Are the Common Mistakes?
🗣️ Answer: The most fatal mistake most often made in society and in the business world is merely writing the annotation “This note is security” or “This is a security note” on the front or back of the note. According to the settled decisions of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), the mere presence of such abstract wording on the note does not remove the note’s negotiable instrument status (that is, its quality of being capable of being put into enforcement). For a note to be accepted legally as a security note, the following conditions must be present together: On the note there must be an express reference such as “This note is the security for the contract dated … concluded between the parties and cannot be endorsed”. More importantly, the main contract in question must also contain, to the last detail, a clause such as “As security for this contract, a note in the amount of …, with serial number …, has been delivered. The note will be returned when the contract is successfully concluded”, and a photocopy of the note must be attached to the back of the contract. Otherwise, enforcement courts will treat the note as an ordinary debt note and will begin seizure proceedings against you.
❓ Question 3: Are Security Notes Requested From Employees When They Are Hired Legally Valid?
🗣️ Answer: It is known that employers, in particular, request blank or fixed-amount notes from newly starting personnel (cashiers, drivers, sales representatives, etc.) in order to cover possible losses they may cause the company or to prevent them from leaving suddenly (resigning). By virtue of the mandatory nature of labour law and the principle of protecting the employee, the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) considers these notes, taken at the time of hiring by exploiting the employee’s economically weak position (under pressure), in principle invalid and unlawful. An employer cannot put this note directly into enforcement by claiming the employee has caused the company a loss; it must first bring an action in the labour court and prove the employee’s fault and the amount of the concrete loss incurred. For employees facing such an unjust proceeding to protect their rights and to prevent seizure from coming to their salaries and homes, it is vitally important to work with a professional enforcement lawyer in Kayseri without delay and to start the legal objection processes.
❓ Question 4: How Can Turkish Expatriates Abroad Manage Security Note Crises in Property Leases or Commercial Business in Turkey?
🗣️ Answer: Our expatriate citizens living abroad (in Germany, France, the Netherlands, etc.) frequently sign notes in the nature of security in their real estate investments in Turkey, summer-house lettings or commercial businesses in which they are partners, or, conversely, request security notes from their tenants. Failure to structure the processes properly may lead to sudden unjust seizures being placed on expatriates’ bank accounts or land titles in Turkey. Our citizens abroad do not need to travel to Turkey in person to resolve such valuable-paper crises, to review contracts, or to stop unjust enforcement proceedings. Through a power of attorney they will grant remotely via the Turkish Consulate in the country where they are located to our corporate office based in Kocasinan, Kayseri (Mutlu Apt, İstasyon Mahallesi, Sıraselviler Caddesi, Barbaros, Şafak Sk. No:1 Kat:3, No:12, 38080 Kocasinan/Kayseri), we conduct all processes on their behalf. As Akdivit Hukuk Law Office, we intervene in unjust proceedings on behalf of our clients through UYAP (National Judiciary Informatics System), review the contents of contracts, and prevent grievances over rights.
❓ Question 5: Which Legal Remedies Should Be Resorted To if an Unjust or Unfounded Security Note Is Put Into Enforcement?
🗣️ Answer: If a bad-faith creditor, even though the provisions of the contract between the parties have been performed, puts the security note in its hands into proceedings through the Enforcement Office like an ordinary debt note, a “Payment Order for Enforcement Proceedings Specific to Negotiable Instruments (Seizure Route)” (Form No. 10) is sent to the debtor. In this case, there are two basic legal remedies open to the debtor:
-
Objection to the Proceedings at the Enforcement Court (5 Days): The debtor must, within the strict and narrow 5-day period from the service of the payment order, apply to the Enforcement Civil Court and request the cancellation of the proceedings by asserting that the note is a security note and that the source of the debt is subject to a condition. However, the enforcement judge looks only at what is written on the note; if there is no clear reference to a contract on the note, the judge rejects this objection.
-
Negative Declaratory Action (Menfi Tespit) in the General Courts: If no result is obtained from the enforcement court, or if the 5-day period is missed, the debtor’s only refuge is the “Negative Declaratory Action (Declaration That the Debtor Does Not Owe)” to be filed at the Civil Court of General Jurisdiction or the Commercial Court. In this action, it is proven that the note was left without consideration by examining the main contract between the parties, witnesses, commercial books and bank records. In order to prevent irreparable losses, it is essential to obtain an interim injunction, by depositing 15% security, that stops the money in the enforcement cashier from being paid to the creditor. The fact that the process involves such high financial risks makes corporate support from an expert lawyer in Kayseri team necessary.



