Disputes over use, division or sale may from time to time arise between co-owners over movable or immovable property owned by several persons in the form of shared ownership or joint ownership. Especially in real estate such as plots, fields, houses and apartment buildings that have passed by inheritance, the failure of the heirs to come together and reach a joint decision makes it impossible to manage the property. In such cases, the legal route that ends the co-ownership relationship between the co-owners and enables a transition to individual ownership is called the “Co-Ownership Dissolution Case” (Ortaklığın Giderilmesi Davası) or, by its older legal name, the “İzale-i Şüyu Case”. As can also be seen in Google search statistics, the topic of “dissolution of co-ownership” is among the leading subjects on which legal help is most needed in the field of real estate and inheritance law in our country. In this article, we will discuss in detail the elements of the case, the conditions for filing it, the methods of sale and the working of the process before the Kayseri Civil Courts of Peace (Sulh Hukuk).
What Is a Co-Ownership Dissolution Case (İzale-i Şüyu)?
The co-ownership dissolution case is the name of a two-sided case (one that has no winner and loser in the classic sense) that puts an end to joint ownership of an asset subject to collective ownership (shared ownership or joint ownership), enabling each co-owner to receive their own share independently, in cash or in kind.
According to the Turkish Civil Code, unless there is a statutory or contractual impediment, each of the co-owners may at any time demand the division of the property. Through this case, the court either physically divides the common property among the co-owners or sells it through enforcement and distributes the proceeds.
Who Are the Parties to the Case? (Who Can File It?)
-
Plaintiff: Any one of the co-owners or heirs can file this case alone. The permission or approval of the majority of the other co-owners is not needed. An application to the court by a single shareholder is sufficient for the case to begin.
-
Defendant: It is mandatory for all the other co-owners other than the co-owner filing the case, who are named in the title deed record or in the certificate of inheritance (veraset ilamı), to be added to the case as defendants. If even a single shareholder is not included in the case, the case will be dismissed on procedural grounds. If one of the co-owners has died, their heirs must also be found and added to the file.
What Are the Methods of Dissolving Co-Ownership?
When examining the request for dissolution of co-ownership, the judge decides on the basis of two main methods. The method that takes priority by law is division in kind (aynen taksim).
1. Dissolution of Co-Ownership by Division in Kind (Aynen Taksim)
If the surface area, zoning status and number of co-owners of the immovable property subject to the case (for example a large plot or field) permit, the court decides that the property be physically divided among the co-owners.
-
Conditions: The share falling to each co-owner after the division must represent an independent economic value and must not be contrary to zoning legislation. A division made in an apartment building suitable for condominium ownership, so that one flat falls to each co-owner, also falls within this scope. If a difference in value arises between the shares, the judge may decide that it be balanced by adding money (ivaz) to the deficient share.
2. Dissolution of Co-Ownership by Sale (The Most Frequently Applied Method)
If it is not possible to physically divide the immovable property among the co-owners (for example where it is a single flat, a single shop or a field too small to be divided), the court decides to dissolve the co-ownership by sale.
-
Public Auction Procedure: The immovable property is sold by a court decision through the Enforcement Sales Office or the Civil Court of Peace Sales Office by way of public auction.
-
Condition of Sale Among Co-Owners: As a rule, these sales are open to everyone. However, if all the co-owners unanimously consent, it may be decided that the auction be held only among the co-owners. If even one of the co-owners wishes it to be sold openly to outsiders, the court must make the sale public. The proceeds of the sale are distributed to the shareholders in proportion to their shares in the title deed, after deducting court costs, fees and attorney’s fees.
Which Court Is Competent and Has Jurisdiction?
The court with subject-matter jurisdiction in co-ownership dissolution cases is the Civil Court of Peace (Sulh Hukuk Mahkemesi). The court with territorial jurisdiction is the court of the place where the immovable property subject to the case is located. If the real estate subject to the case is within the boundaries of Kayseri, the case must be filed before the Kayseri Civil Court of Peace. If several immovable properties are in different cities, the co-ownership of all the properties can be dissolved in a single file by filing the case before the court of the place where any one of the properties is located.
What Does the Claim of Ownership of Improvements (Muhdesat) in the Case Mean?
One of the most complex legal situations encountered in co-ownership dissolution cases is the “muhdesat” claim. Muhdesat refers to structures built later on a common plot or field, such as buildings, houses, trees or vineyards.
-
Problem: The plot is common property belonging to all the heirs, but the 3-storey building on it may have been built by only one of the heirs with their own money.
-
Solution: If one of the co-owners claims that the structure on the immovable property belongs to them and the other co-owners do not accept this, the court gives the plaintiff a period to file a “Case for Ownership of Improvements” (Muhdesatın Aidiyeti Davası) before the Civil Court of First Instance (Asliye Hukuk Mahkemesi). Until this case is concluded, the co-ownership dissolution case is made to wait as a preliminary issue. Once it is clear to whom the building belongs, when the sale proceeds are distributed, the value of the building is paid to that co-owner and the value of the plot is paid to all the co-owners in proportion to their shares.
Case Costs and Who Pays the Attorney’s Fee?
By its nature, this type of case is a “two-sided” case. That is, even though the person who files the case first pays the fee and the expense advance (notification, expert and site inspection costs) out of their own pocket, at the end of the case all the trial costs and the fixed attorney’s fees awarded in favour of the parties’ counsel are charged to all the co-owners in proportion to their shares in the title deed. The costs therefore do not remain only with the plaintiff but are divided among the co-owners.
Conclusion and the Importance of Legal Consultancy
The co-ownership dissolution case, which thousands of people search for on Google every month, is a highly technical process requiring expertise, involving the examination of title deed records, the error-free determination of the chain of heirship, and the processes of objecting to site inspection and expert reports. Failure to follow the case properly may lead to the real estate being sold below its value, delays lasting for years and serious financial losses. In particular, in order to protect the shares, to raise improvement claims in time and to avoid loss of rights at the sale stage, obtaining professional legal support from an experienced team of inheritance lawyers in Kayseri for your real estate and inheritance disputes in the Kayseri region will be the right step for the process to conclude quickly and in your favour.



