A will is the unilateral legal act by which a person who leaves an estate makes dispositions over their assets to take effect after their death. Although people declare their wishes in this way while alive, wills opened after death may not always be found fair or lawful by the statutory heirs. The Turkish Civil Code (TMK) grants the statutory heirs the right to request the annulment of the disposition where circumstances exist that vitiate the validity of the will. This subject, which frequently becomes the object of disputes in practice and creates a caseload in the courthouses, is also searched for most on the internet under the heading “grounds for annulment of a will”. In this article we will discuss the grounds for annulment provided by law, the time limits for filing a case and the legal processes.
What Is a Will Annulment Case?
A will annulment case is an inheritance law case by which a will that the deceased prepared without complying with the conditions provided by law, or with a defective will, is eliminated retroactively by a court decision.
A will does not become invalid by itself. Even if there is a situation contrary to law or to form, the persons concerned must, after the will has been read out by the Civil Court of Peace (Sulh Hukuk Mahkemesi), file an annulment case before the Civil Court of First Instance (Asliye Hukuk Mahkemesi). The legislator has provided a limited number (numerus clausus) of grounds for the annulment of a will.
Grounds for Annulment of a Will Under the Turkish Civil Code
Article 557 of the Turkish Civil Code expressly regulates in which cases dispositions upon death can be annulled. The 4 main grounds for annulment in this article are as follows:
1. The Deceased Lacked Capacity to Dispose (Incapacity)
At the time the will is made, the deceased (the testator) must be of sound mind and have the capacity of discernment (temyiz kudreti). By law, anyone who has completed the age of 15 and has the capacity of discernment can make a will.
-
Ground for Annulment: If, while preparing the will, the deceased had lost the capacity of discernment due to advanced dementia, Alzheimer’s, mental illness, mental weakness or a temporary cause (alcohol, the effect of medication, etc.), the will is vitiated.
-
Process of Proof: The court examines the health reports and hospital records from the day the will was made and requests an official report from the Council of Forensic Medicine (Adli Tıp Kurumu) on “whether the person had capacity to dispose”. If incapacity is proven, the will is annulled.
2. The Will Was Made as a Result of Mistake, Deception, Intimidation or Coercion (Defect of Will)
The deceased must have made the will entirely of their own free will, without being under pressure. Where the will has been corrupted, annulment of the will comes onto the agenda.
-
Mistake (Error): The deceased falling into an essential error about the person or the assets they bequeathed.
-
Deception (Fraud): A person intentionally steering the deceased with false statements so that they make a will in a certain direction.
-
Intimidation and Coercion (Threat/Duress): Having a will signed under the pressure that a serious danger would be brought against the life, property or honour of the deceased or their relatives.
3. The Content of the Disposition, or the Conditions or Charges Attached to It, Are Contrary to Law or Morality
It is essential that the clauses and conditions in the will are not contrary to the general rules of law, mandatory provisions of law and the general moral structure of society.
-
Examples: Where the deceased tells the heir “I am leaving you this house on condition that you do an unlawful act”, or stipulates an immoral condition, the relevant provisions, or the whole will, become the subject of an annulment case.
4. The Will Was Made in Breach of the Formal Requirements Provided by Law (Defect of Form)
In our law, wills are subject to strict formal requirements. Wills that are not made in the form provided by law are annulled because of the defect of form.
-
Errors in an Official Will: In an official will, which must be made before a notary or a judge of the Civil Court of Peace with the participation of two witnesses, choosing the witnesses from persons prohibited by law (e.g. the spouse, ascendants or descendants of the deceased, or persons who will receive a share from the will) is a defect of form.
-
Errors in a Handwritten Will: A handwritten will must be written from beginning to end in the deceased’s own handwriting, must clearly bear the day, month and year (date) on which it was made, and must be signed. A text typed on a computer and merely signed cannot be regarded as a handwritten will and is annulled directly.
Time Limits in a Will Annulment Case (Forfeiture Periods)
Filing a will annulment case is not an unlimited right. In the interest of the estate being settled as soon as possible and of legal certainty, the legislator has set strict forfeiture periods (TMK 559):
-
1-Year Period: The right to file an annulment case lapses when 1 year has passed from the date on which the plaintiff learned of the disposition (the will), of the ground for annulment and of their own entitlement.
-
10- and 20-Year Maximum Periods: In any event, the right to bring a case is completely extinguished once 10 years have passed from the date the will was opened against defendants acting in good faith, and 20 years against defendants not acting in good faith (those who committed fraud or coercion).
Conclusion and the Importance of an Inheritance Lawyer
A will annulment case is a technical process that requires the analysis of medical reports, the evaluation of witness statements, the meticulous examination of formal requirements and the following of complex Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) case law. If the case is lost, a division of property that does not reflect the true will of the deceased may become official, and financial losses that are impossible to repair may arise. For this reason, in order to avoid loss of rights in will processes, to prove vitiated wills on a legal footing and to conduct the case properly, working with an expert inheritance lawyer in Kayseri for your disputes in Kayseri and the surrounding provinces is of great importance for the success of the case.



