Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci Kayseri

Who Owns the Jewelry Given at the Wedding? Return of Wedding Gold (Ziynet) in Divorce Cases and the Court of Cassation’s Latest Criteria

  • Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci
  • 13 min read
Düğünde Takılan Takılar Kimin? Yargıtay’ın En Güncel Ziynet Kararı rehberi

In Turkish society, weddings rest on a deep-rooted tradition in which, besides celebrating the formation of the marital union, ziynet items (gold, bangles, jewelry) and lump-sum cash are given as gifts to provide financial support to the newlyweds. However, once the marital union ends in divorce, the question of to whom this jewelry and money given at the wedding legally belongs, and whose personal property it should be considered, turns into a major financial and legal crisis between the parties. Although the Civil General Assembly of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) and its relevant chambers applied for many years an unshakeable precedent that “all ziynet belongs to the wife, regardless of who it was pinned on at the wedding”, they have recently made very fundamental and radical changes to these rules. Knowing these up-to-date criteria is vital in order not to lose your rights in divorce cases and to be able to properly claim the return in kind of the gold or its cash value. As a law office with extensive case experience in family law and divorce cases in Kayseri and the surrounding provinces, we take a close look at the principles for dividing wedding jewelry through 10 basic questions and answers.

❓ According to the Court of Cassation’s Latest Decisions, Who Does the Gold and Money Given at the Wedding Fundamentally Belong To?

🗣️ The old rule that the Court of Cassation applied for many years was that all jewelry, money and gold given to the bride or groom at the wedding belonged entirely to the wife (was the wife’s personal property), unless there was a contrary local custom or agreement. However, in order to achieve a division more consistent with the essence of the right of ownership and with fairness, the Court of Cassation has changed this view.

According to the latest case law, the new legal criterion for division is as follows: All ziynet items and lump-sum cash given to the wife during the wedding belong to the wife without hesitation. For jewelry given to the groom, a new distinction has been introduced: jewelry given to the groom that is clearly suitable for the wife’s use (e.g. a woman’s bangle, a woman’s necklace) is still regarded as belonging to the wife. However, ziynet given to the groom that is not suitable for the wife to wear (e.g. a man’s wristwatch) and lump-sum cash given to the groom (banknotes in TL, euros or dollars) are regarded as the husband’s personal property.

❓ How Are Wedding Jewelry and Money Thrown into a Common Bag or Chest Divided in Divorce?

🗣️ In today’s weddings, instead of guests coming one by one to the bride and groom and pinning jewelry on them, the practice of dropping money and gold in envelopes into jewelry chests or common bags placed in a corner of the hall has become quite widespread. In this case, because it cannot be physically determined whether the jewelry was intended to be given to the bride or to the groom, great legal uncertainty arises.

The Court of Cassation’s current solution on this subject is to examine local customs (customary law). If there is a definite local custom in the region where the wedding was held (e.g. in the Kayseri area) as to whom the jewelry dropped into the chest is regarded as belonging to, that rule is applied first. However, if no such custom can be proven, the lump-sum cash and ziynet dropped into the common chest or bag are divided equally, half and half (50% – 50%), between the bride and the groom. Jewelry such as woven bangles and earrings, which were dropped into the common box but are of a kind that the wife can wear, continue to be regarded as the wife’s personal property.

❓ Can the Gold Pinned on the Bride by the Groom’s Side (the Mother-in-Law / Father-in-Law) Be Reclaimed in Divorce?

🗣️ One of the most frequent arguments in divorce cases is the groom’s family claiming back, as the marriage ends, the high-value sets and bangles they pinned on the bride at the wedding, saying “our family gave these, we want them back”. Legally, this situation has a clear answer: the act of pinning jewelry at a wedding is legally a contract of “Gift” (donation).

Whether the bride’s side or the groom’s side pinned it, all ziynet items pinned on the bride during the wedding have become the bride’s personal property. The party who pinned the jewelry is deemed to have completely given up the right of ownership at the moment the pinning was completed. For this reason, there is absolutely no legal right to claim back, at the divorce stage, the gold that the mother-in-law or father-in-law pinned on the bride at the wedding by saying “it was bought with our money”. The wife can request the return of this jewelry from the husband through the court.

❓ If the Wedding Gold Was Spent During the Marriage to Buy a House or Car or to Pay Debts, Must the Husband Pay It Back?

🗣️ A situation we encounter very often in family structures in the Kayseri region is the gold being cashed in right after the wedding and used as the down payment on a house, to buy a car, to close wedding debts, or to be put into the capital of the husband’s commercial company. In a divorce case, the husband frequently raises the defence “We spent the gold for our common life, I have no gold or anything”.

However, the Court of Cassation never legally accepts this defence on its own. If the husband cashed in and spent this gold, which is the wife’s personal property, during the marriage, he is obliged to pay this gold back to the wife in kind or in cash. The husband can be freed from this obligation only on one condition: he must prove, with a written document or with unshakeable evidence in court, that the wife “donated (gave as a gift) this gold without any obligation of repayment” so that a house/car could be bought for her. Even if the wife willingly gave the gold to her husband saying “let our home be saved, let our debt be closed”, this does not remove the husband’s duty of repayment.

❓ How Is the Return of Wedding Jewelry (a Ziynet Claim) Requested in a Divorce Case?

🗣️ The return of jewelry pinned at the wedding can be requested within the divorce case, or, while the divorce case is ongoing or after the divorce judgment has become final, by filing an entirely independent “Ziynet Items Claim Case”. If this request is to be made within the divorce petition, the court fees must be paid in full.

In the petition, the type, number, grams and carat of the jewelry pinned at the wedding (e.g. 5 twisted bangles of 22 carat at 20 grams, 1 necklace with quarter gold coins, etc.) must be written out one by one in list form. In our request, we primarily ask for the “Return in Kind” of this gold (that is, for it to be physically taken from the jeweller and delivered), and, if that is not possible, for the current market value on the date of the case to be paid in cash (in TL) together with interest. In these cases, working with a divorce lawyer in Kayseri who is an expert in family law is vital for preparing the gold list completely.

❓ How Is It Proven in Court Which Jewelry Was Pinned at the Wedding? What Is the Strongest Evidence in Ziynet Cases?

🗣️ In ziynet claim cases, the burden of proof lies with the wife, who alleges that the gold is no longer in her possession, that it was taken from her by the husband, or exactly how much gold was pinned at the wedding. The most unshakeable and strongest way of proving the number and existence of the gold pinned at the wedding is Wedding Video Recordings and Wedding Photographs.

The court sends the submitted wedding videos and photographs to an expert jeweller expert witness for examination. The expert witness pauses the video second by second and reports one by one all the gold pinned on the bride and the groom, the thickness and carat of the bangles, and the amounts of money. In addition, family photographs taken right after the wedding, the records of the jeweller where the gold was cashed in, bank account movements and the testimony (witness statements) of close relatives who attended the wedding are the strongest means of proof presented in court.

❓ What Is the Limitation Period in Ziynet Claim Cases? Can the Gold Be Claimed Years After the Divorce?

🗣️ In cases for the return of wedding jewelry, the limitation period varies entirely according to the nature of the claim, and this is one of the procedural rules on which the most mistakes are made in the courthouses. If the wedding jewelry is still physically in existence and you are asking the court for the return in kind of the gold, this is regarded as a “claim for recovery of property (istihkak davası)” based on the right of ownership, and there is no limitation period at all. Even 20 years after the marriage has ended, the gold can be reclaimed if it still physically exists.

However, if the gold was cashed in or spent during the marriage and you are asking the court for the cash value (the money) of the gold, this is now regarded as a claim under the law of obligations. In cases claiming the cash value of the gold, the limitation period is 10 years from the date on which the divorce case became final. The 10-year period is strict and a forfeiture period; once the period has passed, the right can no longer be claimed.

❓ Does the “I Took My Jewelry” Clause in an Uncontested Divorce Protocol Prevent a New Case from Being Filed Later?

🗣️ The protocol texts prepared in uncontested divorce cases, in which the spouses reach agreement between themselves and divorce in a single hearing, produce very strict legal consequences. If the uncontested divorce protocol contains a clause such as “The parties have no ziynet claim against each other, all the jewelry has been divided”, and this protocol was signed before the judge and became final, the wife can never again file a new case and claim the wedding gold.

In practice, however, women sometimes sign the “I took my jewelry” clause because of pressure or threats from their spouse, or out of a desire to get divorced as soon as possible, and after the divorce is over they wish to file a case, stating that they were deceived. Going back on this clause after the protocol has become final is extraordinarily difficult legally; however, if it can be proven with very serious and concrete evidence (e.g. police station complaints, threatening messages) that the free will was vitiated by fraud, intimidation or threat, the route of annulling the protocol may be pursued. For this reason, having the protocol reviewed by a corporate law office in Kayseri before it is signed provides vital protection.

❓ Can the Gold Set as a Religious Marriage (Mahr) Be Requested Separately from the Wedding Jewelry?

🗣️ Although the Turkish Civil Code recognises the civil marriage as the only valid marriage contract, the practice continues in our society of also holding a religious marriage ceremony alongside the civil marriage and of promising the wife, at that time, as a guarantee, a “Mahr (mehir)” (generally a certain amount of gold or property). The Court of Cassation accepts the mahr that the husband promises the wife during the religious marriage as a valid “Promise of Gift” under the Code of Obligations.

Therefore, the amount set as mahr in the religious marriage (e.g. 100 grams of gold) is an additional claim, entirely independent of the ordinary jewelry pinned at the wedding. If the marriage ends in divorce, the wife can, in addition to the wedding jewelry, request payment in kind or in cash of the mahr gold promised to her in the religious marriage through a separate case filed before the Civil Court of First Instance. Proving the mahr deed with a wet-ink signed document or with witnesses is sufficient for winning the case.

❓ Why Is Working with a Lawyer Important in Ziynet Cases and What Is the Role of the Akdivit Hukuk Law Office?

🗣️ Cases for the return of wedding jewelry are a very delicate area of family law expertise that depends entirely on the rules of evidence, the technical analysis of expert reports and the rapidly changing up-to-date case-law criteria of the Court of Cassation. Failing to submit the wedding videos properly in the case, errors in the gram calculations of the gold, missing the limitation periods, or failing to prevent the husband’s moves to hide assets, such as spending the gold during the marriage, can cause you to suffer an enormous financial loss in a process in which you are in the right.

As the Akdivit Hukuk Law Office, operating at our address based in Kocasinan, Kayseri, we defend our clients’ rights at the highest level in ziynet disputes. We examine your wedding videos second by second with our expert teams, prepare the gold list with millimetric precision, and secure the collection of the value of the gold by having the necessary precautionary injunction annotations placed on the husband’s bank and land registry records. Our aim is to win back for you, under the maximum protection of the law, the financial savings that are your right from the marriage.

Conclusion: Entrust Your Future and Your Financial Rights to Reliable Hands

The gold and money given at the wedding are, as a woman’s married life ends, her greatest financial guarantee for the future and her legal right. Do not under any circumstances allow these rights to be wasted in the courthouse corridors through anger, panic or hearsay. Remember that our legal system protects not merely those who are in the right, but those who defend their rights within the statutory period, in accordance with the Court of Cassation’s latest rules and with professional instruments.

The Akdivit Hukuk Law Office is ready, at its modern law office in Kocasinan, Kayseri (Mutlu Apt, İstasyon Mahallesi, Sıraselviler Caddesi, Barbaros, Şafak Sk. No:1 Kat:3, No:12, 38080 Kocasinan/Kayseri), to listen to you, to analyse your wedding records and ziynet files down to the finest detail, and to present you with the clearest and most beneficial road map. For all your family law disputes, from your ziynet claims in divorce cases to your claims for mahr, child support (iştirak nafakası) and alimony for hardship (yoksulluk nafakası), you can contact us at any time and confidently entrust your legal struggle to the defence strength of an experienced and dynamic team.

This article is general information and is not legal advice for a specific case. Every file is different.

Get in touch to discuss your situation

Call, write on WhatsApp or use the contact form.