Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci Kayseri

Simplified Trial Procedure in Criminal Law: Trial Without a Hearing and Its Legal Consequences

  • Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci
  • 7 min read
Ceza Hukukunda Basit Yargılama Usulü ve İtiraz Süreçleri

In order to conclude proceedings within a reasonable time, protect the right not to be stigmatised and ease the workload of the courthouses, the Turkish criminal justice system has incorporated a number of alternative resolution methods and special trial procedures into the Criminal Procedure Code (CMK). The mechanism most frequently encountered in practice, and one that produces highly critical legal consequences for both the defendant and the victim, is the “Simplified Trial Procedure”. Unlike the classic criminal trial, this system is conducted without opening a courtroom hearing, entirely on the basis of the documents in the file and written statements, and it can lead to serious loss of rights if the procedural rules are not observed. In courthouses such as Kayseri, where the caseload of the courts is very high, this process must be followed with great care. In this article we will examine it down to the finest detail from the perspective of an experienced criminal defence lawyer in Kayseri: its scope, how it works, the sentence reductions it provides and the mechanisms for objecting to the judgment.

What Is the Simplified Trial Procedure and What Is Its Main Purpose?

The simplified trial procedure, regulated in Article 251 of the CMK, is a special trial model that allows a judge to deliver a judgment, without holding a hearing, by examining the file, in minor offences expressly permitted by law.

The main purpose of introducing this procedure is to prevent offences that cause relatively little social disruption from being caught up in complicated hearing schedules that last months or even years. In this way, the state’s costs of trial are reduced and the parties are not worn down for long periods in the corridors of the courthouse. However, the absence of a hearing does not mean that the right to a fair trial or the right of defence is restricted; in this procedure the legislator has safeguarded the right of defence through the mechanism of written statements.

For Which Offences Can the Simplified Trial Procedure Be Applied?

For a court to apply the simplified trial procedure in a criminal case, the statutory penalty for the offence must remain below a certain threshold. The clear limits drawn by the law are as follows:

  • Penalty Threshold Criterion: The court may decide to apply this procedure only in offences that fall within the jurisdiction of the Criminal Court of First Instance (Asliye Ceza Mahkemesi) and whose statutory upper limit is imprisonment of 2 years or less or directly a judicial fine.

  • Main Offences Within the Scope of Application: In offence types such as simple assault and battery, insult, simple threat, damage to property, violation of the inviolability of the residence or simple theft, after the court accepts the indictment prepared by the public prosecutor’s office, the judge may, exercising discretionary power, transfer the file to this procedure.

In Which Cases Can It Never Be Applied?

Even where the penalty limit of the offence is below 2 years, the legislator has prohibited the simplified trial in certain personal or legal circumstances. This procedure cannot be applied if the defendant is a minor (children pushed into crime), is mentally ill, or is deaf and mute. In addition, the general (hearing-based) trial is mandatory for offences whose investigation or prosecution depends on permission or on a request, and where several offences have been committed together and one of them does not fall within the scope of the simplified trial.

How the Process Works Technically and the Critical 15-Day Defence Period

When the indictment prepared by the public prosecutor’s office after completing the investigation is accepted by the Criminal Court of First Instance, and the judge decides that the file is suitable for the simplified trial, the process moves entirely to a written stage:

  1. Notification Stage: The court sends the indictment by official notification to the defendant, the victim and, if any, the complainant. This notification expressly warns that the case will be conducted under the simplified trial procedure.

  2. Written Defence Period: The parties who have been notified are given a strict period of 15 days to submit to the court their statements against the charges, their evidence, and their petitions for acquittal or complaint.

  3. Judgment on the File: After the 15-day statutory period has expired, the judge does not organise a hearing at the courthouse attended by the parties. The judge examines the police reports, camera recordings, forensic medical reports and the written defences sent by the parties contained in the file, and at the end delivers a decision of acquittal, conviction or no ground for imposing a penalty on the basis of the file.

At this stage, the legal language of the defence petition to be written and the way the evidence is presented are of vital importance. Since everything that could be explained orally at a hearing must be fitted into this petition, the process must be managed by a professional criminal defence lawyer in Kayseri.

A Major Advantage for the Defendant: A 25% Statutory Sentence Reduction

The legislator has granted a legal advantage to the defendant who contributes to resolving the case quickly and without a hearing. Pursuant to Article 251/3 of the CMK, if the defendant is convicted as a result of the simplified trial procedure, the judge is obliged to apply a direct reduction of 1/4 (25%) to the resulting sentence.

This reduction is not left to the discretion of the court; it is a mandatory provision of law. For example, a person who would normally receive 12 months’ imprisonment following a trial with a hearing will receive 9 months’ imprisonment directly when the case is resolved through the simplified trial. Depending on the circumstances, this sentence may also be converted into Deferment of the Announcement of the Verdict (HAGB) or into a judicial fine.

The Objection Process Against a Simplified Trial Judgment and the Return to the General Trial

If the decision delivered on the file does not satisfy the parties, a statutory objection mechanism has been provided to set that decision aside.

  • Objection Period: The decision must be objected to by submitting a written petition to the court that gave the judgment within 7 days of the notification of the decision to the parties. This period is a forfeiture period; if even one day is missed, the decision becomes final.

  • Return to the Hearing-Based System: The moment the decision is duly objected to, the decision given under the simplified trial procedure becomes completely void. The court automatically converts the file to the general trial procedure (the hearing-based system). The judge sets a hearing date, issues summonses to the parties, calls the witnesses and the trial starts from scratch under the classic procedure.

The Very Critical Risk of Objecting (The Possibility of an Increased Sentence)

Defendants generally act with the thought “I have the right to object anyway, let me try my luck at the hearing”. However, there is a very serious legal risk here: If the defendant objects to the simplified trial decision and, as a result of the hearing-based case that is opened, the judge again concludes that the defendant is guilty, the 25% (1/4) sentence reduction granted in the simplified trial is completely cancelled. At the end of the hearing, the defendant may face a heavier sentence with no reduction. For this reason, before an objection petition is filed, the chance of acquittal in the file must be analysed with great precision by experienced High Criminal Court (Ağır Ceza) lawyers in Kayseri.

Conclusion

To sum up, although the simplified trial procedure is a modern system that speeds up the justice mechanism, it is an unforgiving structure because it proceeds entirely on written documents and is bound to very narrow time limits (15 days for defence, 7 days for objection). A legal argument left out of the petition, or an objection not made within the time limit, may result in a permanent stain on a person’s criminal record or in unjust sentences. To prove your case on the file with the strongest legal arguments, to prevent loss of rights and to manage the process without putting that 25% statutory reduction at risk, you can work with the expert team of Akdivit Law Office in all your criminal disputes and confidently benefit from our professional criminal defence services.

This article is general information and is not legal advice for a specific case. Every file is different.

Get in touch to discuss your situation

Call, write on WhatsApp or use the contact form.