In our law, divorce cases do not end with the parties merely ending the marriage; they also bring with them very important financial disputes such as custody, alimony, compensation and the division of the jewellery (ziynet items) given to the spouses at the wedding. Because the gold, bracelets, money and jewellery sets given at the wedding become significant economic assets when the marriage ends, they are one of the biggest sources of conflict between spouses. There is a fundamental rule in Turkish civil procedure law: “Everyone is obliged to prove their claim.” Therefore, in a ziynet claim filed together with the divorce case or as an independent case after the divorce, the existence of the jewellery and who holds it must be proven with precision. As an expert divorce lawyer in Kayseri resolving family law disputes in Kayseri and the surrounding provinces, we will discuss in detail, in line with the current case law of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), to whom wedding jewellery belongs, the methods of proving jewellery in divorce, and the strongest evidentiary mechanisms to convince the court.
To Whom Does Wedding Jewellery Belong According to the Most Recent Decisions of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay)?
In past years, the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) applied a rigid rule that “according to custom and tradition, all ziynet items are regarded as belonging to the woman, regardless of whom they were given to at the wedding.” However, in view of the changing social structure and the principles of equity, the Court of Cassation has introduced a very critical softening and update to this case law. According to the current criteria:
-
Items Given to the Woman and Items Designated for Her: Any gold, bracelets, jewellery sets and money given to the woman at the wedding are indisputably regarded as the woman’s personal property and must be returned. Likewise, even if given to the man, jewellery suitable for the woman’s use (e.g. a woman’s necklace, a woman’s watch, earrings) is regarded as belonging to the woman.
-
Items Given to the Man and General Money: Jewellery given to the man and clearly designated for the man’s use (e.g. a men’s wristwatch) is regarded as belonging to the man. Apart from that, with regard to fixed sums of money given to the groom or ziynet items put into a shared pouch, the court examines local customs, the agreements between the parties and the intention with which the jewellery was given.
How Is Jewellery Proven in Divorce? The 4 Strongest Pieces of Evidence
In ziynet cases, the claimant (usually the woman) must prove that a certain amount of gold was given to her at the wedding, and that this gold was sold during the marriage or remained with the man when she left the shared home. The main legal evidence used to convince the judge of these claims is as follows:
1. Wedding Videos and Photographs (The Most Concrete Proof)
Video recordings and photographs taken during the wedding form the backbone of the process of proving jewellery in divorce. When the case is filed, this visual material is submitted to the court file. The judge hands the file over to a jeweller expert. By watching the video second by second, the expert itemises one by one how many twisted bracelets the bride and groom are wearing, roughly what the carat and weight of the gold given are, and how much money was thrown onto the sashes or into the pouch, and prepares a report based on the current market value.
2. Witness Statements
Relatives, neighbours or wedding hall staff who attended the wedding can be heard in court as witnesses. However, it is not enough for witnesses merely to say “Yes, a lot of gold was given at the wedding.” They must give clear, first-hand information about where the gold was kept during the marriage, whether it was sold when a house or car was being bought, or whether the woman was able to take the jewellery with her on the day she had to leave the home.
3. Dowry Deed or Jeweller Invoices
If a dowry deed was signed between the parties when the marriage was established, or if there are invoices showing the quantity of the jewellery, these documents also constitute conclusive evidence in court.
4. Bank Records and Safe Deposit Box Information
If it can be proven with documents that the gold was sold and the money deposited in a bank account, that a term deposit account was opened in the name of one of the spouses, or that a safe deposit box was rented at a bank and the jewellery placed there, the court calls for the records from these official institutions and establishes who is in the right.
Does the Defence “We Sold the Gold to Buy a House” Save the Man?
The defence that the man’s side most often relies on in contested divorce cases is: “Yes, this gold was given at the wedding, but during our marriage we bought a car and a house, or we sold this gold by mutual consent to pay off debts.”
The Court of Cassation has drawn a very clear red line on this: the fact that the ziynet items, which are the woman’s personal property, were sold for a house, a car or debts does not remove the man’s obligation to repay this gold. Unless the man can prove with conclusive written evidence that the gold was “gifted to her not to be returned”, he is obliged to pay the woman in cash, at the divorce stage, the value of all the gold that was sold.
Conclusion
Cases on proving jewellery in divorce and on the return of ziynet items are extremely technical cases in which the rules of procedure, expert reports and witness statements collide with precision, and in which the slightest mistake or missing piece of evidence may cause you to lose savings amounting to hundreds of thousands of liras that you are entitled to. Failing to present the wedding videos properly, or failing to have the right questions put to the witnesses, because of hearsay information on the internet or misguidance, may result in the dismissal of the case.
To defend your legal rights to the fullest before the Family Courts of the Kayseri Courthouse, to collect the current value of your wedding jewellery in full, and to prevent irreparable financial losses, you can work with the expert team of divorce lawyers at Akdivit Law Office (Akdivit Hukuk Bürosu) and benefit with confidence from our professional legal consultancy services.



