Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci Kayseri

Partition Action (Izale-i Şuyu): Strategies to Prevent a Court-Ordered Sale for Those Who Say “I Don’t Want to Sell My Share”

  • Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci
  • 13 min read
İzale-i Şuyu Davası Hissemi Satmak İstemiyorum Diyenler İçin Yasal Rehber

In real estate that has been inherited or is held in shared (co-)ownership, a partition action (izale-i şuyu), filed by one of the co-owners because of a need for cash, family resentments or a failure to reach agreement at the table of voluntary division, usually triggers a wave of panic and worry among the other co-owners. In particular, co-owners who do not want to lose their ancestral fields, the family home full of memories or the shop that brings in regular income start looking for an answer to the question “I want to keep my place, I don’t want to sell my share in the partition action, is there no way to stop this sale?” when they see the notification from the courthouse. First, it must be understood that these actions, filed under the Turkish Civil Code, do not mean that the property will definitely be sold to outsiders. With the right legal arguments, properly drafted defence petitions and strategic interim actions, there are ways to protect your share and to prevent the property from going to an outsider. As a law office with extensive case experience in real estate and inheritance cases in Kayseri and the surrounding provinces, we examine all the legal rights available to citizens who do not want to sell their share and the keys to a defence before the court.

❓ What Is a Partition Action (Izale-i Şuyu) and Can a Property Be Forcibly Sold at the Request of Just One Co-Owner?

🗣️ A partition action (ortaklığın giderilmesi) is a two-sided type of action that brings to an end, through the court, co-ownership or joint ownership of movable or immovable property when it cannot be resolved by agreement between the co-owners. The legislator has adopted the principle that no one can be forced to remain a co-owner of a property forever.

For this reason, even if all the other co-owners who hold 99% of the property do not want it sold, the action can lawfully be filed by a single co-owner holding a tiny share of just 1% applying to the Civil Court of Peace (Sulh Hukuk Mahkemesi). In other words, as a rule, when one of the co-owners files an action, the court must resolve this dispute, that is, end the co-ownership. However, ending the co-ownership does not mean the direct sale of the property to outsiders through enforcement. The legal alternatives presented to the judge can steer the course of the case entirely away from a sale.

❓ What Is a Request for Partition in Kind (Aynen Taksim)? How Does the Strongest Way of Preventing a Sale Entirely Work?

🗣️ The first, most fundamental and strongest defence that a person who says “I don’t want to sell my share” in a partition action can raise in court is, legally, a request for Partition in Kind (Aynen Taksim). Under Article 699 of the Turkish Civil Code (TMK), when ending the co-ownership the judge must primarily choose to divide the property in kind (partition); converting the property into money by selling it is by law the last resort.

If the property at issue is a large plot of land, extensive agricultural land, fields, or an apartment building with enough flats for each co-owner to receive an independent unit, we request that the court divide the property and distribute it. Upon this request, the court writes to the land registry and zoning directorates and appoints an expert. If there is no obstacle under zoning laws and soil conservation laws to dividing the property geometrically and legally, the judge divides the property among the co-owners and new separate title deeds are registered in everyone’s name. In this case the property is definitely not sold and your share is fully protected.

❓ How Do Zoning Legislation and the Soil Conservation Law Affect Our Request for Partition in Kind?

🗣️ For a request for partition in kind to be accepted by the court, the property in question must be divisible under the relevant legislation. For example, when partition in kind is sought for a large inherited agricultural field in Kayseri, the “Minimum Agricultural Land Size” limits in Soil Conservation Law No. 5403 are examined down to the last detail. If, once the field is divided, the portion falling to each heir would fall below the statutory limits, the court has to reject the request for partition in kind in order to preserve the agricultural integrity of the land.

Similarly, when a zoned plot in the city centre is to be divided, the “minimum parcel sizes and road frontage requirements” in the Kayseri Metropolitan Municipality zoning regulation are examined. If the division would result in unzoned, unusable, speculative plots, the judge rejects partition in kind. For a single flat, shop or small residence, partition in kind (division) is by nature not possible.

❓ How Is Division Carried Out through Compensatory Payment (Ivaz İlavesi) and How Are Shares Protected?

🗣️ When division in kind (partition) of the property appears possible but the values of the divided parts are not exactly equal to one another, the legal balancing mechanism applied by the court is called Compensatory Payment (Ivaz İlavesi). For example, if a large inherited plot can be divided into 3 equal parts, but one of the parts has a much higher value than the other two because it fronts onto the road, full equality has not been achieved.

In this case, on behalf of the parties who want to protect their share and prevent a sale, compensatory payment is requested from the judge. The co-owner who receives the higher-value part is obliged to pay the other co-owners, whose parts are of lower value, an amount in cash (the compensation) determined by the court. In this way, the property is prevented from being sold and passing into the hands of outsiders, and through a fair division everyone keeps their presence in the property and their share.

❓ How Can the Auction Be “Closed to Outsiders” and Held Only among Co-Owners?

🗣️ If partition in kind is entirely impossible both in fact and in law (for example, if it is a single apartment flat or shop), the court will necessarily rule that the co-ownership be ended by sale of the property. At this stage there is a very critical legal right to prevent the property from being sold to an outside third party and to keep it in the family.

Under the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (İİK), if all the co-owners in the case agree unanimously (or agree at the hearing), they can request from the court that the sale be held only among the co-owners. If all co-owners agree on this, the judge adds the note “The auction shall be held only among the co-owners” to the sale decision. In that case, no one from outside, no outsider, can take part in the auction. The property is put up for auction only among you and the other co-owners. In this way, by purchasing the share of the co-owner who wants to sell at a suitable price, you or other family members can ensure that the whole property stays within the family.

❓ How Can I Save My Share If the Other Co-Owners Do Not Consent to Closing the Sale to Outsiders?

🗣️ If the party who filed the action or the other co-owners act in bad faith, or do not consent to the auction being held only among the co-owners because of hostility between them, the court must conduct the sale “Publicly (Open to Everyone)”. In this scenario too, a financial-legal strategy must be put into play to protect your share and your property right.

As a co-owner you have the legal right to take part in the auction in person. Moreover, when an outside buyer wins the auction, the buyer must deposit the entire price of the property in cash at the enforcement office’s cashier, whereas you are exempt from depositing the money in proportion to your own share. For example, if you enter the auction of a house in which you hold a 50% share and place the highest bid, you become the owner of the whole house by paying only the money for the other side’s 50% share. Since the money for your own share does not have to come out of your pocket, your chance of winning the auction is much higher than that of an outsider.

❓ How Can the Sale Be Delayed or Prevented by Objecting to the Property Value (Valuation, Kıymet Takdiri) Determined by the Court?

🗣️ In partition actions, the panel of experts appointed by the judge examines the location of the property, comparable properties and the current market value, and prepares a “Valuation Report (Kıymet Takdiri Raporu)”. This report is the most vital document determining at what price the property will be put up for auction in enforcement. Parties who do not want to sell their share, or who are concerned that the property will go for less than its value, have the right to file a Valuation Objection Action within 7 days against this report.

We object by demonstrating, with concrete comparables, that the experts calculated the value of the property too low and that current real estate price increases in the region were not reflected. In this case the court appoints a new panel of experts and has the value of the property recalculated. This process both prevents unjust losses by ensuring that the property reaches its true value, and pushes the sale process back by months, gaining you very valuable time to make financial preparations or to persuade the other co-owners at the table.

❓ How Do I Prove That the House or Trees on the Plot Belong Only to Me? What Is an Action for Ownership of Improvements (Muhdesatın Aidiyeti)?

🗣️ One of the most common crises on plots and fields in Kayseri and the surrounding area is that the property appears in the land registry only as “plot”, while on it stands a house, a country house or hundreds of fruit trees (improvements, muhdesat) that only one of the co-owners built or planted with his or her own money. If no precaution is taken, when the plot is sold in the partition action, the house on it is also distributed to all co-owners in proportion to their shares in the plot, which is a very great injustice.

When faced with such a situation, while the partition action is continuing we file an “Action for Ownership of Improvements (Muhdesatın Aidiyeti)” before the Civil Court of First Instance (Asliye Hukuk Mahkemesi). The moment this action is filed, the Civil Court of Peace is compelled to treat the partition action as a “Preliminary Issue (Bekletici Mesele)” and the sale is stopped entirely. Once we prove in the improvements action that the house was built solely with your money, an annotation is placed on the land registry record. From that point on, even if the property is sold, while the plot portion of the total auction price is distributed among the co-owners, the entire value of the house (the structure) is paid to you alone, down to the last kuruş. This can completely kill the other co-owners’ appetite for a sale and even lead them to withdraw from the case.

❓ How Does an Action for “Conversion of Joint Ownership into Co-Ownership” Affect the Sale Process?

🗣️ When a decedent dies, the type of title deed issued in the heirs’ names is “Joint Ownership (Elbirliği Mülkiyeti)”. In this type of ownership no one’s share is clearly separated; everyone is a co-owner of the entirety of the property. Before or during the filing of a partition action by one of the co-owners, the other co-owners can apply to the Civil Court of Peace to request the Conversion of Joint Ownership into Co-Ownership (Paylı Mülkiyet).

With this action, everyone’s inheritance share ratios are registered numerically and clearly in the land register (for example, as 1/4 or 3/8). Once the ownership has been converted into co-ownership, the co-owner who “does not want to sell his or her share” legally gains the right to sell his or her own share to a third person, or the power to dispose of it. Also, because the process of moving to co-ownership directly affects the procedural steps of the main case, when it is structured with the right legal timing it becomes one of the most important parts of our share-protection strategy.

❓ How Important Is Working with a Lawyer in Partition Actions and What Is the Role of Akdivit Law Office?

🗣️ Although partition actions (izale-i şuyu) may look from the outside like a simple process of selling a property, behind them lie very heavy, technical details of real estate law, such as zoning legislation, soil conservation laws, strict deadlines for objecting to expert reports, improvement claims and enforcement auction procedural rules. Failing to submit defence petitions on time, failing to defend the conditions for partition in kind with scientific data in court, or failing to object to the valuation within the time limit can lead to your invaluable properties and rights being suddenly sold in enforcement for next to nothing.

As Akdivit Law Office, serving from our corporate office based in Kocasinan, Kayseri, we defend with full professionalism the property rights of our clients who say “I do not want to lose my share”. From the moment your file is opened, we review the title deed and zoning records, push for the possibilities of partition in kind, block sale processes with interim actions, and prepare financial-legal structures that will conclude the auction within the family even in the worst-case scenario. Our aim is to keep your real estate rights, your most valuable asset, under the maximum guarantee of the law.

Conclusion: Do Not Leave Your Property Rights and Your Future to Chance

The filing of a partition action concerning a property in which you are a co-owner does not mean that you will definitely lose that property. The biggest mistake you can make is to act in panic, not to attend hearings, or to leave the process to itself by saying “I hold the majority, they can’t sell”. Remember that the law protects not only those who own assets, but those who defend their rights within the legal time limits, in the proper manner and with expert legal arguments.

Akdivit Law Office is ready, at its modern corporate office in Kocasinan, Kayseri (Mutlu Apt, İstasyon Mahallesi, Sıraselviler Caddesi, Barbaros, Şafak Sk. No:1 Kat:3, No:12, 38080 Kocasinan/Kayseri), to listen to you, to analyse the title deed, zoning and survey records of the property at issue down to the finest detail, and to draw you the clearest roadmap of protection. To defend your rights in your partition actions, and to protect your share to the maximum extent with your requests for partition in kind, valuation objections and improvement ownership actions, you can contact us at any time and confidently entrust your legal struggle to the experienced and dynamic defence power of a corporate team.

This article is general information and is not legal advice for a specific case. Every file is different.

Get in touch to discuss your situation

Call, write on WhatsApp or use the contact form.