Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci Kayseri

What Is Marriage Annulment? Conditions of the Annulment (Butlan) Lawsuit and Limitation Periods

  • Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci
  • 7 min read
Nikah İptali Nedir? Evliliğin İptali (Butlan) Davası Şartları ve Zamanaşımı Süreleri

In our law, marriage is an official bond formed by the parties mutually declaring their affirmative intent before the competent marriage officer. However, in the ordinary course of life, behind the marriage that has been solemnised there may be violations of the mandatory provisions of the law, serious tricks that impair the parties’ will, threats or major deceptions. In such cases, instead of ending the marriage with an ordinary “divorce case,” it is possible to seek its removal by arguing that the marriage was defective from the very beginning. This mechanism, regulated in the Turkish Civil Code (TMK) as “Annulment of Marriage” or, by its legal name, the “Butlan Lawsuit,” is commonly searched among the public as marriage annulment. Annulment of a marriage is subject to far stricter legal conditions and time limits than an ordinary divorce process. In this authoritative guide, we examine annulment of marriage processes in all their legal detail, based on the most frequently asked questions.

❓ Question 1: What Does Marriage Annulment (Annulment of Marriage) Mean in Law? How Does It Differ from Divorce?

🗣️ Answer: Annulment of marriage is the removal, by court decision, with retroactive or prospective effect, of a marriage that was solemnised without complying with legal conditions or with one party’s will having been impaired by deceit, intimidation or mistake. The point most commonly confused in society is the difference between divorce and annulment. In a divorce case, a marriage that was validly and flawlessly formed is ended prospectively on grounds that arise later (incompatibility, adultery, etc.). In a marriage annulment case, however, there is a fatal legal defect, one that violates the law or impairs the will, present at the very moment the marriage was formed (at the marriage table). In other words, the annulment lawsuit aims either to cure a defect at the birth of the marriage or to treat that birth as if it never happened. Until the court gives an annulment decision, the marriage continues to produce all its legal consequences; however, the moment the decision becomes final, the marriage is annulled by the court.

❓ Question 2: In Which Cases Can Annulment of the Marriage Be Sought on the Ground of “Absolute Nullity”?

🗣️ Answer: The Turkish Civil Code divides the grounds for annulment of marriage into two: serious grounds concerning public order (Absolute Nullity, mutlak butlan) and relatively lighter grounds concerning the personal will of the parties (Relative Nullity, nisbi butlan). The grounds of “Absolute Nullity” (definite invalidity) regulated in Article 145 of the TMK are as follows:

  • One of the Spouses Being Married at the Time of Marriage: The second marriage of a person who, without legally ending their first marriage, solemnises a marriage a second time through an error or irregularity in the civil registry is tainted by absolute nullity and is annulled.

  • One of the Spouses Lacking the Capacity to Discern at the Time of Marriage Due to a Permanent Cause: The marriage of a person whose mental faculties are not sound to the degree that they did not know what they were doing at the time of the marriage is invalid.

  • One of the Spouses Having a Mental Illness of a Degree That Bars Marriage: The marriages of persons with mental illness who, according to an official health board report, have a medical impediment to marrying are subject to annulment.

  • Existence of Kinship Between the Spouses of a Degree That Bars Marriage: Marriages solemnised between the close relatives listed in the law (between ascendants and descendants, siblings, and paternal or maternal uncles and aunts and their nieces and nephews) are contrary to public order and are annulled directly. The Public Prosecutor may also file these lawsuits ex officio.

❓ Question 3: How Is a Marriage Annulled through “Relative Nullity” in Cases of Deception, Threat or Mistake?

🗣️ Answer: “Relative Nullity,” regulated in Articles 148-151 of the TMK, concerns situations in which one party’s will has been impaired. In the following cases, the aggrieved spouse may request annulment of the marriage:

  • Mistake (Error): This is the case where a person sits at the marriage table by mistake although never wanting to marry, or by being qualifiedly mistaken as to the personality (identity) of their spouse.

  • Deception (Fraud): Agreeing to marry by believing the lies of one’s spouse or of a third person. For example, a spouse concealing a chronic, sexually transmitted or fatal illness (or impotence) that would make married life impossible, or concealing a very serious criminal conviction in their past, amounts to fraud and is a ground for marriage annulment.

  • Intimidation (Threat): A spouse who was forced to say “yes” at the marriage table out of fear, as a result of a serious and imminent danger being created to the life, health or honour of themselves or one of their relatives, may file a relative nullity lawsuit and have the marriage annulled.

❓ Question 4: What Are the Forfeiture Periods in an Annulment of Marriage Lawsuit? What Happens If the Deadline Is Missed?

🗣️ Answer: In Absolute Nullity cases, which concern public order (e.g. where a person is already married or where there is close kinship), there is no time limit for filing; they can be filed at any time as long as the marriage continues. However, for a spouse who will seek annulment of the marriage on grounds of “Relative Nullity” such as deception, intimidation or mistake, the law has prescribed very strict “forfeiture periods” (hak düşürücü süre). Under Article 152 of the TMK, the right to file an annulment lawsuit lapses 6 months after the date on which the mistake or deception (fraud) was learned or the effect of the fear (threat) ceased, and in any case when 5 years have passed since the marriage. Because these periods are forfeiture periods, the moment the 6-month period is exceeded, the person’s right to file a marriage annulment lawsuit is lost forever. In this case, the only legal remedy left to the aggrieved spouse is to structure the process as an ordinary “contested divorce case” and to prove the other party’s fraud/fault there and claim compensation. To track the time limits to the day, it is vitally important to contact an expert divorce lawyer in Kayseri without losing a second.

❓ Question 5: What Path Should Expatriates Living Abroad Follow to Annul a Marriage Solemnised in Turkey?

🗣️ Answer: Our citizens living abroad (Germany, France, the Netherlands, etc.) may sometimes enter sham (collusive/fake) marriages solely to obtain a residence permit, a visa or citizenship, or, when they come to Turkey, may be married off through major deceptions (concealment of illnesses, lies about assets) and be pushed to be taken abroad. When our expatriate citizens face such an international fraud or threat, they do not have to come in person at great travel expense to protect their rights in Turkey. By going to the Turkish Consulate in the country where they are, they can manage the entire process professionally with a power of attorney granted remotely to our corporate office in Kocasinan, Kayseri (Mutlu Apt, İstasyon Mahallesi, Sıraselviler Caddesi, Barbaros, Şafak Sk. No:1 Kat:3, No:12, 38080 Kocasinan/Kayseri). As the Akdivit Law Office, on behalf of our expatriate clients we file annulment of marriage lawsuits before the Family Courts through UYAP (the National Judiciary Informatics System) without missing that critical 6-month forfeiture period, and we protect their rights to the highest degree by submitting the necessary doctor/hospital reports or evidence of fraud to the file.

This article is general information and is not legal advice for a specific case. Every file is different.

Get in touch to discuss your situation

Call, write on WhatsApp or use the contact form.