Under the Turkish Civil Code, divorce cases are based entirely on fault, regardless of the gender of the parties. There is a general misperception in society that the rights to compensation and alimony in divorce cases belong only to women. Yet our legal system aims to protect the party who is without fault or less at fault. Our expatriate citizens, whether living in Turkey or following divorce proceedings abroad, must analyse their rights and obligations correctly. In this article, we examine in the most detailed way, in a question-and-answer format, the compensation and alimony disputes that we frequently come across in search engines.
❓ Question 1: Can a Husband File a Compensation Claim Against His Wife in a Divorce Case?
🗣️ Answer: Yes, in a divorce case a man can also file a case for material and moral compensation against his wife if the lawful conditions are met, and he can win it. Under Article 174 of the Turkish Civil Code, the sole condition required for claiming compensation is that the claimant be “without fault or less at fault than the other party”. If the woman is found to be seriously at fault in the events that caused the foundation of the marriage union to be shaken (for example infidelity, trust-shattering behaviour, leading a dishonourable life or physical/psychological violence against the spouse), the husband has the right to claim both material compensation for the impairment of his existing and expected interests and moral compensation for the violation of his personality rights. Therefore, the answer to the question of whether a man can file a compensation case against a woman depends entirely on how the parties’ fault ratios in the events leading to the divorce are proven in court.
❓ Question 2: Is It Possible to Be Awarded Alimony in Case of Equal Fault?
🗣️ Answer: If the court finds the parties “equally at fault” in divorce cases, different practices apply depending on the types of alimony. According to our law, the party who will fall into poverty because of the divorce can claim indefinite alimony (poverty alimony) from the other party in proportion to the other party’s financial capacity for their living; however, the condition for this is that the fault of the person claiming alimony is “not heavier”. In other words, it is legally possible for the parties to claim alimony (poverty alimony) in case of equal fault, because being equally at fault satisfies the condition of “not being more heavily at fault”. The current decisions of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) also provide that poverty alimony can be awarded in favour of an equally at-fault spouse (if they will truly fall into poverty because of the divorce). However, it should not be forgotten that in case of equal fault the parties absolutely cannot obtain material or moral compensation from one another. The “child support alimony” awarded for the care of joint children, on the other hand, is awarded in every case regardless of the fault ratio of the mother or father, entirely with regard to the best interests of the child.
❓ Question 3: How Are Fault and Rights Proven in Divorce?
🗣️ Answer: Establishing who is in the right before the court and determining the parties’ fault ratios is possible only by submitting lawfully obtained evidence to the file. Witness statements, message records, hotel check-in lists, social media posts or bank account transactions are the most frequently used means in determining fault. To avoid loss of rights and especially to ensure that the alleged faults are characterised correctly within the legal framework, working with an expert divorce lawyer in Kayseri who is familiar with Kayseri Courthouse practice and building the defence strategy with them will determine the fate of the case.



