Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci Kayseri

Are WhatsApp Messages Evidence in Court? Validity Conditions in Divorce and Criminal Cases

  • Av. Ezgi Akdivit Lafci
  • 5 min read
WhatsApp Yazışmaları Mahkemede Delil Sayılır mı? Boşanma ve Ceza Davalarında Geçerlilik Şartları

The central place that smartphones and instant messaging applications have taken in our lives has fundamentally changed the types of evidence submitted in legal disputes. Especially in family law (contested divorce, infidelity, concealment of assets) and criminal law (threats, insults, fraud) cases, parties most often submit WhatsApp messages and screenshots taken from the application to the courts in order to prove they are in the right. However, the fact that digital data can easily be manipulated, altered or fabricated raises the question of to what extent courts will accept these messages as “conclusive or discretionary evidence”. In light of the most recent case law of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) and decisions of the Constitutional Court, we examine the fate of digital data in court in full detail.

❓ Question 1: Are WhatsApp Messages and Screenshots Legally “Lawful Evidence”?

🗣️ Answer: Under Article 199 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK), messages, voice recordings, e-mails and digital data that serve to prove the facts in dispute are of the nature of a “document”. Therefore, in principle, WhatsApp messages can be submitted to the court as evidence (documents). However, the most basic condition for digital data to be used as the basis of a judgment is that this evidence has been obtained “by lawful means”. WhatsApp messages obtained by secretly installing spyware on the phone of a person, a spouse or someone else, by forcibly breaking its password or by means of threats constitute unlawful evidence. Pursuant to Article 38 of the Constitution, findings obtained unlawfully can absolutely not be accepted as evidence by the courts and cannot be used as the basis of a judgment. In contrast, conversations in a group chat the person is part of, or insulting or threatening messages sent directly to them, constitute lawful evidence; because here it concerns the person’s own freedom and sphere of communication.

❓ Question 2: Can WhatsApp Messages Prove Infidelity (Unfaithfulness) in Contested Divorce Cases?

🗣️ Answer: In family law practice, especially in contested divorce cases based on adultery or leading a dishonourable life, conversations held over WhatsApp are one of the strongest means of proof. Trust-shattering, emotional or sexual messages, photo sharing and voice recordings exchanged by one of the spouses with a third person directly affect the determination of fault in the divorce case. According to the established decisions of the family chambers of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), while the marriage union continues, taking a screenshot of messages accidentally left open on a computer/phone in the home the spouses live in together that is not locked or is open for shared use is not regarded as unlawful evidence and is examined by the court, as long as “it aims to prove the breach of the duty of fidelity and no planned trap was set”. However, since this distinction lies on a very fine line, working with an experienced divorce lawyer in Kayseri on how to present the evidence to the court at the petition stage will eliminate the risk of the case being dismissed and prevent loss of rights.

❓ Question 3: Can WhatsApp Messages Deleted Be Retrieved Retroactively by Court Order?

🗣️ Answer: One of the most commonly misunderstood issues in society is the perception that a court can write to the WhatsApp company and request old message records. WhatsApp is a US-based company that uses an end-to-end encryption protocol and declares that it does not store users’ message content as text on its own servers. For this reason, no court or public prosecutor’s office in Turkey, through the cybercrime unit, can officially obtain the content of deleted past conversations from WhatsApp headquarters. Courts can only request from GSM operators (Turkcell, Vodafone, Türk Telekom) on which date and time and from which IP address phone numbers consumed internet data (HTS records); but the content of the messages never appears in these records either. Therefore, deleted messages can only be proven by physical examination of the phone device and by the examination of backup files on the phone (cloud or local database backups) by digital forensics experts and court-appointed experts.

❓ Question 4: How Is an Objection Raised in Court Against Fake WhatsApp Screenshots?

🗣️ Answer: With today’s technology, fake WhatsApp conversation windows can be created in a very short time using various mobile applications or editing tools. If the opposing party manipulates the case with such fake screenshots, an “explicit objection to the evidence and signature” must be made immediately and within the time limit. In this case, the court requests that the physical phone device from which the screenshot is claimed to have been taken be delivered to the court cashier’s office or to the cybercrime branch directorate. The digital forensics expert takes an image (copy) of the device and examines the originality of the message, the date it was sent, its match with the other party’s phone number, and whether any code-level change was made in the device’s database (SQLite). If the phone is not available and only a screenshot printed on paper exists, this data alone will not constitute conclusive evidence. Given this complex nature of digital evidence and the rigidity of criminal/civil procedure rules, building the defence with the support of an expert lawyer in Kayseri who is familiar with the current expert reporting standards at the Kayseri Courthouse is the safest way to prevent irreparable harm.

This article is general information and is not legal advice for a specific case. Every file is different.

Get in touch to discuss your situation

Call, write on WhatsApp or use the contact form.