The institution of “detention on remand” (tutuklama), regulated under the Criminal Procedure Code (CMK), is the most severe protective measure applied in a criminal proceeding before a judgment is given. Because a detention order directly restricts a person’s right to personal liberty and security, which is under constitutional guarantee, it is not a punishment but only a temporary measure aimed at safeguarding the soundness of the proceedings. In practice, however, resorting to detention early and with the logic of punishment in advance can lead to enormous losses of rights that cannot be repaired. Preventing every unjust day that a suspect or defendant spends in prison is possible only with a “petition objecting to detention” that is supported by legal arguments and based on concrete facts. From the viewpoint of an expert criminal defence lawyer in Kayseri who undertakes the defence in serious criminal proceedings in Kayseri and the surrounding provinces, we will cover the legal time limits for objecting to a detention order, the competent courts, the grounds for release, and a professional petition template that you can use directly.
What Is the Time Limit for Objecting to a Detention Order?
In criminal law, applications against measures restricting liberty are subject to very narrow and strict time limits. Under the relevant articles of the CMK, the time limit for objecting to a detention order is 7 days from the day the decision is read in your presence (pronounced) or notified to you.
-
How Is the Period Calculated?: For example, the period starts on the day the detention order is issued in your presence by the Criminal Judgeship of Peace (Sulh Ceza Hakimliği), and the objection petition must be submitted to the court by the end of working hours on the 7th day thereafter. This period is forfeitable; if even one day is missed, the right to object to the detention is lost and one must wait for the next routine detention review (the 30-day period).
Which Court Is the Objection to Detention Filed With?
In objections against a detention order, the competent authority depends on a chain system according to the type and number of the court that issued the decision:
-
Against Decisions of the Criminal Judgeship of Peace (Sulh Ceza Hakimliği): An objection against a detention order issued by the Criminal Judgeship of Peace during the investigation phase is made to the next numbered Criminal Judgeship of Peace in that courthouse. If there is only one Criminal Judgeship of Peace in that courthouse, it is sent to the judgeship in the nearest courthouse.
-
Against Decisions of the Criminal Court of First Instance (Asliye Ceza Mahkemesi): The authority competent to examine the objection is the High Criminal Court (Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi) to which that courthouse is attached.
-
Against Decisions of the High Criminal Court (Ağır Ceza Mahkemesi): The objection is made to the next numbered chamber of the High Criminal Court that issued the detention order (e.g. if the Kayseri 1st High Criminal Court issued it, to the Kayseri 2nd High Criminal Court).
Strong Grounds of Objection That Will Convince the Court to Release
In a petition objecting to detention, forming abstract sentences such as “My client is innocent, we request his release” finds no response with judges. In the petition, it must be proven with legal and concrete grounds that the conditions in Article 100 of the CMK are not met:
-
Absence of Suspicion of Flight: It should be emphasised that the suspect/defendant has a fixed residence, a regular job, family ties and social standing, and therefore will not attempt to flee.
-
Disappearance of the Risk of Tampering with Evidence: It should be stated that all the evidence in the file (camera recordings, witness statements, forensic medicine reports, etc.) has been collected and that the suspect no longer has any opportunity to interfere with or tamper with the evidence.
-
Sufficiency of Judicial Control Measures: Proceeding from the principle that detention is the last resort (ultima ratio), it should be put to the judge that “Judicial Control” provisions such as a travel ban, signing in at regular intervals or house arrest would be more than sufficient to achieve the purpose of the proceedings.
-
Violation of the Principle of Proportionality: The lower limit of the punishment prescribed by law for the alleged offence should be compared with the time the suspect has spent in detention; it should be argued that detention has ceased to be a measure and has turned into a punishment.
📄 SAMPLE PETITION OBJECTING TO DETENTION WITH A RELEASE REQUEST
TO THE KAYSERİ ……………….. HIGH CRIMINAL COURT
To Be Forwarded Through
THE KAYSERİ ……………….. CRIMINAL JUDGESHIP OF PEACE
INVESTIGATION / MERITS NO: [Year / File Number]
OBJECTING TO DETENTION
SUSPECT / DEFENDANT: [Your First Name Last Name] – (Currently Detained in the [Kayseri Closed] Penal Execution Institution)
DEFENCE COUNSEL: [Your Lawyer’s Full Name and Address Details]
SUBJECT: Submission of our objections to the unjust detention order of the Kayseri …… Criminal Judgeship of Peace dated [DD/MM/YYYY], and a request that the suspect be RELEASED or, if the court is of a different opinion, that he or she be released with JUDICIAL CONTROL provisions applied.
EXPLANATIONS:
-
Within the scope of the investigation being conducted against my client, it was decided that my client be detained by the decision of the Kayseri …… Criminal Judgeship of Peace dated [DD/MM/YYYY] and numbered [Interrogation No]. This decision is clearly contrary to procedure and the law and to universal legal principles, and we object within the legal time limit.
-
My client has no risk of flight or of tampering with evidence. My client has a fixed residence in Kayseri and works regularly at the workplace named [Workplace Name]. He or she has a family and children to support. As soon as invited, he or she came personally to the judicial authorities and has shown no intention whatsoever of fleeing justice.
-
All the evidence in the file has been secured. All digital materials, statements and documents relating to the alleged offence have been seized by the law enforcement authorities, and there remains not a single piece of evidence that the suspect could tamper with or alter. The risk of tampering with evidence required by Article 100 of the CMK does not exist in the concrete case.
-
The detention measure is disproportionate. In our law, detention is the last resort among protective measures. It is perfectly possible for the proceedings to run smoothly even with judicial control measures, such as a travel ban or signing in on certain days, applied to my client. The issuing of a detention order directly seriously violates the principle of “Proportionality”.
LEGAL GROUNDS: CMK 100, 101, 267, 268 and the relevant legislation, ECtHR case law.
EVIDENCE: Civil registry record, fixed residence certificate, workplace trade registry gazette, precedent court decisions and the contents of the file.
CONCLUSION AND REQUEST: For the reasons explained above and to be taken into account by your court of its own motion;
We respectfully submit and request, as defence counsel for the suspect, that the unjust detention order of the Kayseri …… Criminal Judgeship of Peace, which lacks any legal basis, be REVOKED, that my client’s detention be lifted and that he or she be RELEASED, or, if your court is of a different opinion, that he or she be released with one of the JUDICIAL CONTROL measures deemed appropriate under Article 109 of the CMK. [DD/MM/YYYY]
Defence Counsel of the Suspect / Defendant
Att. [Your Full Name]
(Signature)
Conclusion and Important Warning
An objection to detention is among the legal processes in a criminal file that are the hardest to reverse and that must be woven with the greatest care. A petition written carelessly and filled with stock sentences from the internet causes the judge to reject the objection outright and this severe situation restricting liberty to continue for months. Spotting the gaps in the file and polishing the favourable evidence in accordance with the criminal procedure law is possible only under the supervision of experienced criminal defence lawyers handling serious felony (Ağır Ceza) cases in Kayseri. In all criminal disputes before the Kayseri Courthouse, to protect your liberty and your rights, you can obtain professional criminal law consultancy from the dynamic and expert team of lawyers at Akdivit Law Office (Akdivit Hukuk Bürosu).



